Skip to main content
EU ready to fine anti-austerity government budget
DOUG NICHOLLS condemns the hypocrisy of opposing austerity in Britain while arguing to stay in the EU with its anti-austerity punishment system
EU ‘help’ for debtburdened countries comes at a high cost

YOU can’t huff and puff about opposing austerity in Britain while also arguing, as some do, that we need Labour to overturn the referendum result and stay in the EU.

The EU has just opened disciplinary proceedings against the Italian government after rejecting its budget proposals.

Italy is the fourth largest industrial economy in Europe and a net contributor to EU coffers — which still don’t get a bill of health from their official auditors.

No-one reading this paper would support the overall politics of the Italian government, but they are taking forward the desires of their own people to end government austerity and to start spending on essential services and infrastructure.

The EU rules state that deficits should not exceed 3 per cent of a country's gross domestic product (GDP) and public debt must not exceed 60 per cent of GDP — a far cry for many European countries. This was introduced by the Maastricht Treaty and a very big reason why many of us on the left in Britain opposed introducing the treaty here without a referendum.

The EU Commission’s vice president Valdis Dombrovskis — not, you will note, an Italian or elected by the Italian people — said: "You cannot cure high levels of debt with more debt, it is a vulnerability that needs to be addressed.”

Indeed Italy’s debt burden, as in many countries these days, is heavy. It is 131 per cent of its GDP and at 2.3 trillion euros (£2 trillion) is the second largest in the euro zone. But that is its business and if they now want to reboot their productive economy by borrowing more to reinvest in public services, no foreign power should prevent them.

But the EU and the finance houses that very much drive its agenda rule over nations by creating debt and other dependencies. One way of making countries dependent is to reduce their self-sufficiency in food and manufacturing production, energy supply and steel. They have done this rather well in Britain and most member states.

Another way is to enforce mass migrations as they did with the accession states, hollowing out the skilled and potential workforces of many countries now desperate to get their nationals back to rebuild their own economies.

Financial debt is the big stick for some, however, and just reflect again on what the EU did to Greece. The banks took over from its elected parliament completely and the EU-backing transnational corporations bought up most of its national assets. They enforced the country into deeper debt and servitude. Proud nations end up paying off the biggest loan sharks the world has ever seen.

We have repeatedly warned on these pages that the related mechanisms of the single market to prohibit meaningful state aid and of other treaties to limit fiscal spending hard-wire austerity in the EU. This cannot be reformed. The EU is trying to retain these mechanisms in the withdrawal agreement with Theresa May expressly to tie the hands of a future independent government of Britain that wants, though for different reasons from the Italian government, to rebuild its economy.

Stop the nonsense. A proper Brexit lays the basis for freeing ourselves from austerity.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (centre front) stands with L
Features / 16 July 2024
16 July 2024
DOUG NICHOLLS, chair of the think tank Rebuild Britain, encourages creative engagement with the new government on economic matters particularly
Delors TUC
Features / 30 December 2023
30 December 2023
DOUG NICHOLLS, former general secretary of the General Federation of Trade Unions and lifelong campaigner against the European Union, reflects on the recent death of one of the main architects of the EU
U.S. President Joe Biden, right, and Chinese President Xi Ji
Features / 16 November 2022
16 November 2022
The GFTU has been running education courses on what is really happening in China and the US, Doug Nicholls reflects on some of the learnings and the importance of the recent US-China talks in Bali
Community organisations Acorn and Southwark Defend Council h
Features / 19 October 2022
19 October 2022
In the second of a two-part feature for TUC week, DOUG NICHOLLS, general secretary of the General Federation of Trade Unions discusses the underestimated strength of community organisations and the value of a new working relationship with trade unions
Similar stories
United States Vice-President JD Vance, right, shakes hands w
Features / 12 February 2025
12 February 2025
The EU and Nato are umbilically tied – but what will the new Trump era and a reconfiguration of US interests mean for the war in Ukraine, asks VINCE MILLS
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves speaks during the
Features / 5 October 2024
5 October 2024
In light of its retreat on green investment, DIANE ABBOTT MP dissects Labour’s economic priorities, questioning whether the promised ‘light at the end of the tunnel’ will materialise amid signs of continued cuts and massive spending on war
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer (centre front) stands with L
Features / 16 July 2024
16 July 2024
DOUG NICHOLLS, chair of the think tank Rebuild Britain, encourages creative engagement with the new government on economic matters particularly
Demonstrators clash with the police during a protest on the
Features / 9 May 2024
9 May 2024
Liberation Day celebrations have brought the dark reality of the Giorgia Meloni government’s fascist origins to the surface as the nation's industrial and political struggles boil over, reports NICK WRIGHT