Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Politics is still an angry, shouty male-dominated arena
Overly aggressive MPs who belittle women not only undermine democracy, they are ridiculous, says EMMA DENT COAD

IN ANY other pub in London, I would expect to walk in unnoticed and buy myself a drink, sit in a corner and ruminate in peace. 

However on the rare occasion, on a late voting night in Parliament, if I wish to have a quiet drink alone in the MPs’ bar, you would think I’d walked into the gents’ toilet by mistake. The world stops. You hear crickets. They stare and snicker. It is unbelievably rude. And of course deliberate. 

Meanwhile, upstairs in the House of Commons, the age-old custom of barracking is a daily trial. It is calculated to intimidate and belittle. 

Visiting schoolchildren tell me they find it unacceptable, it is not how they are taught to behave. One seven-year-old asked me: “Why does Theresa May laugh when you talk about sad things?” 

Good question.

My guiding principle in life has always been that everyone has equal value and importance. To be honest, this causes all kinds of interesting problems. 

People bursting with self-importance cannot adjust to this. Put simply, from their point of view I don’t recognise my place in the pecking order. And I don’t intend to. Ever.

As a journalist and researcher working in the design, architecture and planning arena for most of my working life, I am well used to working in male-dominated environments. 

Some male architects can be arrogant and conceited, but in general, among groups of educated, intelligent, thoughtful and outward-looking people, and particularly in academia, there is less of a gender divide.

So in that world I have always felt like a person with particular interests and expertise first. In Parliament, however, I am seen as a woman first. 

Women have been in Parliament for 100 years, but we are often seen as infiltrators in a boys’ school, where women are tolerated, patronised and a constant irritation. 

I should state here that, while Labour certainly has its dinosaurs, this attitude is undoubtedly more prevalent among right-wing Tories. 

So I’ve heard the argument that to counter this narrative we need more women leaders; Parliament should reflect society. 

But I cannot accept the proposal that women leaders make society more compassionate and humane. 

Two women Tory leaders have headed the most brutal, anti-family governments in recent times, punishing minority groups, immigrants, migrant and other low-paid workers, disabled people, pensioners and working women. 

Meanwhile our male Labour leader is renowned for a lifetime of championing disadvantaged groups of all kinds, and is quite simply loved for it. 

You can’t buy that kind of reputation, and dressing Jeremy Corbyn like a banker — as some would wish — cannot change his soul, any more than an exquisite wardrobe can make our PM a kinder person.

But let’s try to take the personal out of this. The Tory government is intimidated by the strength of the opposition, by the remarkable and forward-thinking manifesto we produced in 2017, by a leader who is unimpeachable, whatever they throw at him in a daily war of attrition.  

When the House of Commons descends into animalistic grunts and shrieks it demeans our democratic process. 

The world is watching, and shocked seven-year-olds cannot believe MPs are allowed, in 2019, to behave like football hooligans in the cradle of democracy. 

When I see MPs whipping each other into a frenzy of shouty self-righteousness, I have to remind myself that it is not merely provocative, alpha-male-dominated behaviour which has been allowed to prevail unchecked. 

It is not merely demeaning to democracy. It is not merely unworthy, violent behaviour. It is also absurd. 

At a local party committee meeting recently I had the temerity to be right on an issue which the male chair had misunderstood. 

I felt I had been courteous in correcting the misunderstanding, but clearly being right on an issue of compliance was a provocation. I was violently sworn at. 

If men in positions of influence and power cannot be politely corrected by a woman without descending to violent verbal abuse, we have a long way to go. 

Politics is an angry and male-dominated place. A lot of people want this to change. 

So, on International Women’s Day, let’s remind men who cannot sit in positions of authority without descending into brutish behaviour, that they are ridiculous. 

And if they swear at you — laugh. 

Emma Dent Coad is MP for Kensington.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Destroyed buildings by Israeli bombardments in the northern
Features / 6 March 2025
6 March 2025
While the US president dreams of a grotesque, neocolonial ‘Riviera of the Middle East,’ Architects for Gaza are working to restore services and rebuild communities on the exact sites of homes destroyed by Israel, writes EMMA DENT COAD
Devastation in Gaza, seen from across the Israeli border
Features / 8 December 2024
8 December 2024
EMMA DENT COAD explains how the 1,000-strong Architects for Gaza alliance is presenting bold ideas for recovery, rebuilding communities, and fostering hope in the aftermath of widespread devastation
Opinion / 27 March 2024
27 March 2024
From more austerity to perpetual war, the party will not fight our battles or defend our most vulnerable, argues EMMA DENT COAD
Campaigner and former Labour MP Emma Dent Coad
Features / 12 January 2024
12 January 2024
Now running as an independent, former Labour MP EMMA DENT COAD looks at how consistent honesty and integrity may be the missing elements needed to drag political leadership out of the gutter
Similar stories
Labour movement banners
Features / 12 May 2025
12 May 2025

Rather than hoping for the emergence of some new ‘party of the left,’ EMMA DENT COAD sees a broad alliance of local parties and community groups as a way of reviving democratic progressive politics

Woman alone
Features / 28 April 2025
28 April 2025

It’s tiring always being viewed as the ‘wrong sort of woman,’ writes JENNA, a woman who has exited the sex industry

LANGUAGE BARRIER: Princess Margaret meeting pop group The Be
International Women's Day 2025 / 8 March 2025
8 March 2025
Decades after Dale Spender’s groundbreaking work on how language embeds male dominance, the struggle to reshape words that accurately reflect women’s experiences remains both vital and unfinished, writes JULIA BARD
STEP BY STEP: Rebuilding life after the trauma of prostituti
Features / 5 March 2025
5 March 2025
As TUC Women’s Conference prepares to debate the decriminalisation of prostitution, EMMA, who exited the sex industry more than nine years ago, reflects on how her harrowing experience changed her initial view that ‘sex work is work’