Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Did Scotland troll the Queen with an egalitarian, republican anthem?
The Duke of Hamilton arrives with the monarch's hat at the Scottish Parliament in Edinburgh yesterday

HEAR that? Was it the sound of Rabbie Burns spinning in his grave at an unforgivable misuse of his egalitarian, republican anthem? Or was it the sound of the Her Majesty the Queen being sensationally trolled?

As Her Maj left the debating chamber at Holyrood on Saturday, she did so to a bagpipe rendition of A Man’s a Man for A’ That, Burns’s classic declamation against defamation.

True, it was performed by Sheena Wellington at the Parliament’s official opening in 1999, and again by Midge Ure in 2016. But that doesn’t stop it being one of the most splendid expressions of a socialist message pre-Marx.

True, Brenda had left the chamber by the time Sturgeon, Swinney et al began to sing. On the pipes, SNP MSP Stuart McMillan seemed oblivious as the singing politicians fell out of tune. And the most visceral lines of Burns’s verse are towards its end:

A prince can mak a belted knight,
A marquis, duke, an’ a’ that;
But an honest man’s abon his might,
Gude faith, he maunna fa’ that!
For a’ that, an’ a’ that,
Their dignities an’ a’ that;
The pith o’ sense, an’ pride o’ worth,
Are higher rank than a’ that.

The Queen and Prince Charles had just listened to a series of pretty deferent speeches from the party leaders – with the admirable exception of Richard Leonard’s, which left the pair of them rather stony-faced. Former Daily Record editor Murray Foote said he was “taken by the chutzpah” of Leonard “decrying multi-millionaire landowners in front of Brenda.”

The royals have entered this unicameral parliament time and time again, while in London the most they can hope for is a door slammed in Black Rod’s face and a reception in the House of Lords.

Now here they were being tunefully told to know their place. But then again, Holyrood always was a place of contradictions.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Symon Hill (right) and (left) an anti-monarchy protest
Features / 10 March 2025
10 March 2025
The police have finally admitted it was totally illegal to arrest me for simply asking who elected King Charles — my ordeal has opened my eyes to the plight of free speech and the right to protest in Britain, writes SYMON HILL
PIETA: Evan Milton (as Lancaster) with Daniel Evans (as Edwa
Theatre Review / 7 March 2025
7 March 2025
GORDON PARSONS admires a version of Marlowe’s grim tragedy that strips it down to its gay essentials
Jonathan Hanks in A Christmas Carol
Theatre Review / 23 December 2024
23 December 2024
SUSAN DARLINGTON enjoys, with minor reservations, the Northern Ballet’s revival of its 1992 classic
Thomas Cromwell in 1532 painted by Hans Holbein the Younger
Features / 21 December 2024
21 December 2024
There is no denying Thomas Cromwell's positive and progressive impact on English politics, argues STEPHEN ARNELL