Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Sajid Javid’s bid to reduce migrants’ rights
SOLOMON HUGHES examines how the Home Secretary’s new regional pay thresholds plan would effectively create a system of ‘pass laws’ to further exploit migrants

HOME SECRETARY Sajid Javid is edging closer towards a nasty policy of regional work permits for migrants, which would use the “hostile environment” apparatus to push all new migrants into a legal status as second-class citizens.

The thing to grasp is that the real sting in post-Brexit government migration policy is not about “numbers” it is about rights. 

The Tories claim that they want to leave the EU because they will have control of migration and be able to reduce “numbers” to satisfy anti-migrant feelings. 

But the government could do something worse — they could keep the level of migration, but make migrant workers coming to Britain have much weaker legal rights. 

This would satisfy both people who have been stirred up to have nasty anti-migrant prejudices, and bad employers who want to have lots of workers they can bully.

This is one way it can start: in June Javid asked the migration advisory committee to look at “regional salary thresholds for different parts of the UK” to cover migrants in new rules being written for 2021. 

That may sound bland or inoffensive, but could drastically reduce migrant rights, putting them much more under control of the boss.

Right now, migrants from within the European Union can come and work here on exactly the same terms as British workers. 

The only exception is that, while they do pay taxes, they can’t vote in general elections — so we have about two million workers who are disenfranchised. That’s bad, but otherwise they have the same workplace rights. 

This is important because, as the union slogan goes, an injury to one is an injury to all. Bad employers have to make special efforts to bully migrant workers and cause division in the workforce.  

The government currently gets the migration advisory committee to set a “minimum salary threshold” for non-EU migrants applying for a “Tier 2” work visa. 

This is set artificially high, at £30,000 a year. Non-EU migrants applying for a work visa must have a £30,000 a year job to enter Britain. 

It is way above average earnings, but the government is OK with that because EU migrants can fill jobs with lower wages. 

There are far more EU migrants than Tier 2 migrants. But after Brexit there will be a lot of pressure from employers to have a lower salary threshold, because it will apply to all migrants, and they want migrant workers to work in many jobs.  

Javid’s solution is to think about regional salary thresholds. He could say there is a particular shortage of workers in Scotland, so migrants could enter Scotland for lower-salary jobs. 

This is sometimes offered as a “liberal” solution, that would allow for higher numbers of migrants. It is actually a policy that was designed by Migrant Matters Trust, a supposedly liberal organisation backed by Tory/Change UK MP Anna Soubry and former Labour home secretary Barbara Roche. 

Except it is profoundly illiberal. It would actually mean we would lose freedom of movement within Britain itself — because the plan also has to stop, say, a young couple who migrated to Scotland from Spain or the Philippines moving to London.  

Regional migrant pay thresholds means a system of work permits. And introducing a system of pass laws. It means the government issuing documents to migrants and then saying: “Can I see your papers please” when they want to move home. 

For the system to work, migrants would need employers to sponsor their work permits. If they wanted to move, they would need a new work permit.

Migration Matters Trust board member Garvan Walshe, an assistant to Tory lord and former minster Pauline Neville-Jones, explained in their version of  the scheme: “It wouldn’t mean Essex posting border guards on M25 off-ramps to keep more free-wheeling London’s immigrants out. Just as most of a bank’s work isn’t conducted by the tellers at the counter, most immigration control happens ‘behind the border,’ by controlling access to welfare, requiring employers to only employ people with permission to work, and so on.”

That’s meant to be reassuring, but it should sound familiar. It is the machinery of the “hostile environment,” where you turn every hospital, workplace, rental agency, bank, benefit office into a border guard. Then apply it to millions more people. 

You create a new category of worker — a category which could apply to literally millions — who have to ask for a stamp from their boss to move job, move house or go to hospital. 

It is an anti-migrant recipe that doesn’t reduce the number of migrants — it reduces migrants to second or third-class citizens. 

In a way that is no surprise: typically economic systems driven by prejudice or racism do not exclude minority workers, even if they claim they will. 

Taking two very extreme examples, South Africa or the southern United States were run on racism. They also had very large black populations. They were not excluded from the country, they were excluded from rights.

This is why what sounds like a bland statement about “regional pay thresholds” is something we have to keep an eye on. Setting up a pass law and work permit system post-Brexit will exploit migrants. 

It will also lead to more exploitation of all workers, because if some of our workmates in every shop, office, works or warehouse have lesser rights, you can bet we will all see our pay and conditions pushed down.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Prime Minister Keir Starmer speaks during a media conference at the end of the Nato Summit at the Hague, Netherlands, June 25, 2025
Features / 27 June 2025
27 June 2025

SOLOMON HUGHES explains how the PM is channelling the spirit of Reagan and Thatcher with a ‘two-tier’ nuclear deterrent, whose Greenham Common predecessor was eventually fought off by a bunch of ‘punks and crazies’

Palestinians receive donated food at a community kitchen in Gaza City, June 10, 2025
Features / 13 June 2025
13 June 2025

Israel’s combination of starvation, coercion and murder is part of a carefully concerted plan to ensure Palestinian compliance – as shown in leaked details about the sinister Gaza Humanitarian Foundation which reveal similarities to hunger manipulation projects in Vietnam, Malaya and Kenya, says SOLOMON HUGHES

Workers protest outside Google London HQ over the
Lobbying / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025

SOLOMON HUGHES reveals how six MPs enjoyed £400-£600 hospitality at Ditchley Park for Google’s ‘AI parliamentary scheme’ — supposedly to develop ‘effective scrutiny’ of artificial intelligence, but actually funded by the increasingly unsavoury tech giant itself

TREACHERY FORGOTTEN: John Woodcock, seen here in 2015, betrayed Labour under Corbyn. Now that the right is back in charge, he is welcome to schmooze Labour MPs for Ramsay Healthcare
Features / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025

SOLOMON HUGHES details how the firm has quickly moved on to buttering-up Labour MPs after the fall of the Tories so it can continue to ‘win both ways’ collecting public and private cash by undermining the NHS

Similar stories
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaking during a press conference on the Immigration White Paper, May 12, 2025
Politics / 31 May 2025
31 May 2025

DIANE ABBOTT MP argues that Labour’s proposals contained in the recent white paper won’t actually bring down immigration numbers or win support from Reform voters — but they will succeed in making politics more nasty and poisonous 
 

ANGER GROWS: Protesters demonstrate in Dover against migrant
Features / 10 April 2025
10 April 2025
The left must confront both far-right bigotry and the undeniable problems the exploitation of migrant workers by the ruling class creates — but there are few lessons from the global left on how to strike this balance, laments NICK WRIGHT
PUBLIC SNUB: People protesters outside the Reform UK Wiltshi
Features / 15 March 2025
15 March 2025
As anti-immigration rhetoric gains mainstream acceptance, trade unions must unite workers across backgrounds while challenging the false narrative that blames migrants for economic hardship, argues TONY CONWAY
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage smoking outside the Westminste
Features / 12 September 2024
12 September 2024
As angry voters reject austerity, social insecurity and endless war across Europe, the left should be the beneficiary instead of the far right. NICK WRIGHT looks at the ideological hangups holding us back from connecting to these dissenters