Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
The Tories: Is the party over? A history of the present
The left might fear Boris Johnson, but he heads a party that looks to be in terminal decline, argues KEITH FLETT

THE coronation of hard-right Tory Boris Johnson as party leader and hence prime minister will no doubt be hailed as a great victory by the Murdoch press and the Mail. 

Elements of the Corbynphobic Labour right won’t lose too much sleep either perhaps, reckoning that of the no-hopers and losers the Tories have available Johnson has the best chance, even if a small one, of beating Labour in a general election.

Yet the reality suggests a sharply different story for the Tories and privately many of them know it.

Former leader William Hague changed the rules for Tory leadership elections in 1998 to provide for a members’ vote between two contenders determined by MPs. 

So far there have been two elections. Iain Duncan Smith won in 2001 with 155,993 votes (60.7 per cent) against Kenneth Clarke, who received 100,864 (39.3 per cent). 

In 2005 David Cameron got 134,446 votes (67.6 per cent) and David Davis received 64,398 votes (32.4 per cent). 

Neither Michael Howard nor Theresa May required a membership vote as they ended up as the only candidate.

We can see a distinct trend from 250,000 votes in 2001 to just under 200,000 in 2005. 

In 2019 a total of 138,809 Tories voted, which is apparently 87.2 per cent of the membership. In less than 20 years the number of Tories voting in a leadership election has declined by well over 100,000.

The declining Tory membership contrasts very strongly with a resurgent Labour Party, not that anyone glancing at the mainstream media would know it. 

When Jeremy Corbyn was elected by Labour members for a second time in 2016 as leader, he received 313,209 votes, with over 500,000 cast in total.

Of course a good number of Tory members from 2001 and 2005, particularly given the average age of Tory members (the most optimistic estimate is late fifties, most suspect its rather older) may simply have passed away in old age rather than left. 

However Ukip certainly did pick up some Tory members (the Brexit Party doesn’t have members). The key point is that this trend affects all organisations but the Tories have been unable to recruit replacements and certainly younger members.

Behind this lies the increasingly important issue of what the Tory Party stands for and who it represents.

Of course we can see that it stands for accepting Islamophobia, racism, sexist discrimination and much else. But more specifically people like Boris Johnson and Jacob Rees Mogg hark back to an imperial past while themselves having personal and business links with sections of capital that are far removed from such a past.

We are some way down the road from the 1960s debate between Perry Anderson and EP Thompson about the nature of the modern British state and its political character.

As Labour has long recognised, the functions of the state continue to operate whichever political party is in office. This increasingly now applies to business, often internationally based, and not overly concerned to support the Tory Party.

Right-wing ideas and the power of capital in British society are not about to disappear unfortunately, but the role of the Tory Party in being their political representative appears to be drawing to a close.

The most distinctive and important thing about a Boris Johnson premiership may simply be that it is the last time a Tory enters No 10 Downing Street.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
WINNING OVER THE WORKING CLASS? Margaret Thatcher (left) personally sells off a London council house in her bid to undermine the welfare state and woo Labour voters via the 1980 Housing Act and so-called ‘right to buy’ for tenants
Features / 26 May 2025
26 May 2025

Research shows Farage mainly gets rebel voters from the Tory base and Labour loses voters to the Greens and Lib Dems — but this doesn’t mean the danger from the right isn’t real, explains historian KEITH FLETT

Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch at their local election campaign launch at The Curzon Centre in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, March 20, 2025
Features / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

KEITH FLETT traces how the ‘world’s most successful political party’ has imploded since Thatcher’s fall, from nine leaders in 30 years to losing all 16 English councils, with Reform UK symbolically capturing Peel’s birthplace, Tamworth — but the beast is not dead yet

STILL MARCHING: A May Day demo makes its way through London, 1973
Features / 1 May 2025
1 May 2025

KEITH FLETT revisits the 1978 origins of Britain’s May Day bank holiday — from Michael Foot’s triumph to Thatcher’s reluctant acceptance — as Starmer’s government dodges calls to expand our working-class celebrations

Features / 14 April 2025
14 April 2025
From bemoaning London’s ‘cockneys’ invading seaside towns to negotiating holiday rents, the founders of scientific socialism maintained a wry detachment from Victorian Easter customs while using the break for health and politics, writes KEITH FLETT
Similar stories
YESTERDAY’S HOPE: Crowds outside the 2017 leaders debate
Features / 6 January 2025
6 January 2025
Every few years, it seems like the ‘right time’ to build a new left party — but what are the right conditions, asks socialist historian KEITH FLETT, looking back at the last two centuries and the insights of Ralph Miliband and EP Thompson
Britain / 5 July 2024
5 July 2024
Starmer and Sunak arrive for their BBC debate in Nottingham
Features / 30 June 2024
30 June 2024
KEITH FLETT offers some historical context to the election campaign’s final period
THE ART OF DEMAGOGY: Reform UK leader Nigel Farage speaking
Features / 29 June 2024
29 June 2024
With far-right parties making major gains recently in Europe, it’s worth paying close scrutiny to Farage’s party and taking the threat it poses seriously, writes DIANE ABBOTT