Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Patel’s asylum system overhaul plans will undermine rule of law and access to justice, lawyers warn
Home Secretary Priti Patel

PRITI PATEL’S planned overhaul of the asylum system will undermine the rule of law and access to justice, lawyers warned as a “sham” consultation on the changes closed this week. 

Under the Home Secretary’s proposed system, asylum-seekers who enter Britain via an illegal route would be denied the right to permanently settle even if their claims are successful. 

Those who come through official resettlement schemes would be granted indefinite leave to remain. 

The Law Society of England and Wales has warned that these changes risk breaching international law by creating a two-tier asylum system. 

“The Home Office plans for the asylum system pose a serious threat to the rule of law as well as undermining access to justice and making a mockery of British fair play,” Law Society president Stephanie Boyce said. 

The Refugee Convention, of which Britain is a signatory, states that people fleeing persecution should not be penalised for taking illegal routes.

The Law Society’s damning comments come in response to a six-week government consultation on the Home Office’s New Plan for Immigration, which closed on Thursday. 

The consultation has previously been slammed as a “sham” by almost 200 refugee, human rights, legal and faith groups which described it as a “thinly veiled public relations exercise.”

The groups said the process was poorly designed, confusing and inaccessible, and used questions that are “clearly designed to lead people into endorsing Priti Patel’s plans.”

The Home Office claims the new system is intended to deter illegal entry to Britain and tackle criminal gangs that facilitate crossings, as well as make it easier to remove people who have no right to be in the country. 

However the Law Society on Thursday said the proposals are “not supported by evidence” and “muddle immigration, asylum and nationality laws.”

This has made it “well-nigh impossible” to give detailed responses to many of the consultation questions, the society added. 

It comes as 60 charities urged the government today to immediately scrap separate changes to immigration rules which allow the Home Office to deport non-British nationals for being homeless. 

In a joint letter, the charities warned the “damaging” policy will deter people from seeking help. 

“It puts people at risk of exploitative work, accommodation, and potentially modern slavery, to avoid sleeping rough and putting themselves at threat of removal from the country,” it warned.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
POLICING THE POLICE: GLC leader Ken Livingstone (centre), wi
Features / 10 March 2023
10 March 2023
In an exclusive investigation, BETHANY RIELLY looks at how the state targeted leading politicians and campaigning groups — labelling many well-known figures 'extremists' and 'subversives' for attempting to hold the police to account
Eritrean female soldiers
Features / 12 December 2022
12 December 2022
On September 4, 16 Eritrean asylum-seekers were arrested at a protest against their country’s dictatorship and its supporters here. Since then, questions have been raised about whether the British authorities are doing enough to protect activists and asylum-seekers from the ‘long arm’ of the regime in Asmara
Similar stories
Channel Migrants
Features / 9 May 2025
9 May 2025

Secret consultation documents finally released after the Morning Star’s two-year freedom of information battle show the Home Office misrepresented public opinion, claiming support for policies that most respondents actually strongly criticised as dangerous and unfair, writes SOLOMON HUGHES

Lord Alf Dubs on stage addressing the crowd during a rally in Parliament Square, London, after taking part in the Refugees Welcome March, September 2016
Features / 6 May 2025
6 May 2025

A recent Immigration Summit heard from Lord Alf Dubs, who fled the Nazis to Britain as a child. JAYDEE SEAFORTH reports on his message that we need to increase public empathy with desperate people seeking asylum

A view of HMP Northeye in Bexhill-on-Sea, East Sussex, which
Britain / 15 November 2024
15 November 2024
Government urged to put ‘clear distance between it and the cruel, wasteful camps policy held by the previous one’