Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Wuthering Heights, Royal Exchange Theatre Manchester
Adaptation of Bronte classic fails to scale the heights
BOISTEROUS: Rakhee Sharma (Cathy) and Alex Austin (Heathcliff)

WHAT a great time to stage a theatrical version of Wuthering Heights, with Storm Ciara and her running-mate Dennis creating havoc.

Sadly, though, their fierce winds and torrential downpours create more passion and fear than this somewhat disappointing production of Emily Bronte’s classic novel.

It all starts so well, with the excellent Sophie Galpin and Becky Wilkie playing haunting guitar, synth drums and keyboard, evoking the perfect eerie and brooding soundscape for the disaster that is about to unfold.

Yet though the early scenes between the boisterous Cathy and Heathcliff work reasonably well, the attempt to lighten the mood with some comedy is misguided.

The relationship between the wild moors and the corresponding intensity of Cathy (Rakhee Sharma) and Heathcliff (Alex Austin) is at the heart of the story and, although Cecile Tremolieres’s set design and Zoe Spurr’s lighting create an evocative moorland, the essential spark between the two lovers is missing – it is hard to imagine that their love runs so deep that only death can release them.

The novel’s narrative of raw, unfettered emotion, passion, torment and a love so intense it becomes destructive is its very essence and has to be the basis of any adaptation.

But tossing in the odd modern parlance and a few fucks at the expense of the story’s heart doesn’t make it more relevant today.  It merely loses its soul.

David Crellan as Earnshaw and Rhiannon Clements as Isabella put in creditable performances and the addition of the few snippets from Bronte’s beautiful poetry works well. But ultimately it’s down to the two wonderful musicians to save the day.

Runs until March 7, box office: royalexchange.co.uk

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Rose Galbraith and the ensemble of Spend Spend Spend
Theatre review / 29 November 2024
29 November 2024
PAUL FOLEY applauds a faultless musical that tells the tragic real-life story of working-class winners of the football pools
Concert review / 30 October 2023
30 October 2023
PAUL FOLEY is blown away by a Brazilian band at the top of their game
(L to R) A banner celebrating of Mark Ashton; Frances Hodgki
Exhibition Review / 24 October 2023
24 October 2023
PAUL FOLEY examines how the Whitworth is attempting to engage with sexual minorites
(Left) Tennessee Williams’ Glass Menagerie at the Royal Ex
Culture / 2 December 2022
2 December 2022
Similar stories
DANGEROUS LIASONS: Dominique Larose and Joseph Taylor in Jan
Ballet Review / 17 March 2025
17 March 2025
SUSAN DARLINGTON applauds the translation of Jane Eyre into a ballet that preserves the drama of her formative years
A STAKE IN THE FUTURE: Annette Badland and Danielle Henry in
Theatre review / 19 February 2025
19 February 2025
PAUL FOLEY recommends an extraordinary double bill that packs a punch and leaves you reeling
Rose Galbraith and the ensemble of Spend Spend Spend
Theatre review / 29 November 2024
29 November 2024
PAUL FOLEY applauds a faultless musical that tells the tragic real-life story of working-class winners of the football pools
Neil Charles
Music review / 7 October 2024
7 October 2024
CHRIS SEARLE is transported by a superfine tribute to James Baldwin