Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
What should we do about ‘degrowth’?
The ‘degrowth’ debate raises critical issues to which only a Marxist approach can provide answers, argues the Marx Memorial Library

PART 1 of this answer argued that environmental destruction is driven by the fundamental contradiction in capitalism — between the forces and relations of production and its relentless drive for profit. Capitalism depends on continued growth, without which it would collapse. Non-exploitative capitalism is a contradiction in terms. There is not a single “human ecology” — every social system has its own ecological dynamic, and capitalism’s is a particularly destructive one. 

Just as capitalism, as an economic system, depends on exploiting workers, so too does it depend on exploiting the resources — living and non-living — of our planet. That was something recognised by Marx and Engels with their concept of the “metabolic rift” between humans and nature. 

Marx focused on agriculture, the depletion of soil nutrients and the pollution of waterways by run-off and human sewage. He was an early advocate of recycling. Today we recognise that the wider impacts of capitalism threaten the whole planet. As Barry Commoner, a Marxist ecologist and one of the founders of the modern environmental movement wrote a half-century ago (at the same time of the MIT computer models discussed in part 1 of this Q&A): 

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Report / 30 March 2024
30 March 2024
ROS SITWELL reports from a conference held in light of the closure of the Gender Identity and Development Service for children and young people, which explored what went wrong at the service and the evidence base for care
Features / 26 October 2023
26 October 2023
ROS SITWELL reports from the three-day FiLiA conference in Glasgow
Features / 7 July 2023
7 July 2023
ROS SITWELL reports on a communist-initiated event aimed at building unity amid a revived women’s movement
Features / 15 July 2019
15 July 2019
London conference hears women speak out on the consequences of self-ID in sport
Similar stories
Full Marx / 11 August 2024
11 August 2024
Most currently popular arguments for degrowth describe a real problem without recognising its true cause – capitalism’s insatiable need to accumulate, argues the MARX MEMORIAL LIBRARY
Full Marx / 27 May 2024
27 May 2024
Marx and Engels’ concern with soil provides a focus for understanding the relationship between capitalism and the environment, argues the MARX MEMORIAL LIBRARY
Full Marx / 8 April 2024
8 April 2024
The impact of AI depends on who controls it and for what purpose, argues the Marx Memorial Library
Full Marx / 28 January 2024
28 January 2024
Social ownership and democratic control of the means of production, distribution and exchange needs to include effective feedback mechanisms to ensure that output and demand are in balance, writes the Marx Memorial Library