Skip to main content
Starbucks Workers United defeats the giant coffee chain
Terrified by the prospect of a union at last, the corporate beast has been flooding the town of Buffalo with company big-wigs and meddling managers to throw the poll — it lost, with the workers voting unequivocally to join, reports MARK GRUENBERG
Starbucks employees and supporters react as votes are read during a viewing of their union election on Thursday, December 9, 2021, in Buffalo, New York

STARBUCKS WORKERS UNITED broke a significant barrier on December 9 with the first-ever worker win at the big retail coffee chain.

Workers at the Elmwood store in Buffalo voted 19-8 to unionise with Starbucks Workers United, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) officer announced.

The union also won 15-9 at a second store, but there are seven challenged ballots and the NLRB will have to decide whether and how many of them to count.

The union lost 8-12 at a third Buffalo-area store, with two challenged ballots and two invalid votes. In one of many tactics management used to try to beat the union, the firm abruptly closed two more stores which had the most pro-union staff and transferred people into other stores.

It also brought in co-founder Howard Schultz and other head honchos to argue against the union.

But when pro-union worker Gianna Reeve stood up at a captive audience meeting and asked Schultz to sign a set of fair election principles, “he ran away,” she said.

And it tried to stuff the ballot box by expanding the proposed bargaining unit from the 70 workers whom Starbucks Workers United wanted to include, to 100.

It scrambled with last-minute improvements and a promised pay raise. And it hired Littler Mendelson, a notorious union-buster which advertises itself as the nation’s top corporate law firm.

The tactics failed as the workers became more determined than ever to get their union.

The Elmwood workers, gathered at their storefront union quarters in Buffalo, erupted in fist-waving cheers and hugs when the results came in.

They literally jumped for joy as they realised their victory was a defeat for a powerful multinational corporation that rakes in profits from stores around the world.

“I’m so proud of the workers in my hometown of Buffalo. Way to go!” declared Howard Kling, a vice-president of the International Labor Communications Association, who lives now in Minnesota.

His organisation was holding a virtual convention of labour communicators when the results at Starbucks were announced.

“There’s been a very clear shift from ‘partners’ to profits. It’s been a churn and burn,” among the workforce, 11-year-worker Michelle Eisen, told a town hall meeting for the workers several days ago, hosted by strongly pro-worker Senator Bernie Sanders.

“Partners” is the Starbucks term for workers, like “associates” at Walmart. Bosses have adjusted even the usage of words in the English language to disguise what they are doing, in true Orwellian style.

Their victory is important: Starbucks, with 9,000 stores and 200,000 workers nationwide, is — like Amazon and Walmart — a domain of low-paid, low-benefit workers.

And those workers, marshaled by the Service Employees, the parent union of Starbucks Workers United and other unions, have been rising up against corporate exploitation for more than a year.

The coronavirus pandemic and the massive job losses it created in the restaurant-bar-hotel sector, already the economy’s lowest-paid, shone a national spotlight on such worker exploitation.

Workers have responded with unionisation drives, or by finding better jobs in the current recovery, telling their old bosses to “take this job and shove it.”

Starbucks tried to cultivate an image that it’s different from those other firms.

“It is a company that I came to because they professed to be a company I would want to work for, one of the better ones and someone who cared about the community and their employees and the environment,” said Eisen.

“And in the last few years — and this predates the pandemic — things have changed. There’s been a slide in the working conditions and a very clear shift in how they value their employees and I definitely have felt undervalued.

“Since we went public on August 23, we’ve seen something that’s very contrary to what Starbucks says they are, at least to the public … We’ve seen our stores inundated with Starbucks corporate from all over the country.”

Besides Schultz and Starbucks North America President Roxanne Williams, “They’ve sent ‘support partners’ to prevent us from talking about the union with our co-workers. They’re called ‘support managers,’ but we know they’re there to surveil us and prevent us from doing the work we’d like to do.”

There were so many managers that one male barista, working at the store on a Sunday, found himself surrounded in a “captive audience” meeting with nine managers and HR reps.

“What I’d like to see after we have our union is to have a seat at the table, a say in our working conditions and a say on our pay. I mean someone hired tomorrow is going to make 63 cents less an hour than I do after 11 years with the company and that’s unacceptable.”

The gap is so narrow, Eisen added, because while she’s had small raises, the newer workers benefit from New York state’s rising minimum wage.

She doesn’t begrudge them that. The state minimum wage is $12.50 an hour outside the New York City metro area, rising to $13.20 on December 31. It’s $15 an hour in the city, its suburbs and Long Island.

“What is clear is that senior employees are not valued the way we should be, given the time and energy we’ve put into this company,” Eisen added.

This article first appeared on www.peoplesworld.org.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
UNION-BUSTING: Protesters against Elon Musk on Tuesday outsi
Features / 6 February 2025
6 February 2025
The US president has cancelled all federal union contracts as ‘un-American,’ saying ‘It’s our dream to have everyone work in the private sector,’ writes MARK GRUENBERG
 LIVES RUINED BY CORPORATE GREED: Trees sway in high winds a
Features / 20 January 2025
20 January 2025
California’s real-life water theft makes the classic Jack Nicholson film Chinatown look tame as a billionaire couple diverts resources and the climate crisis worsens the city’s peril, reports MARK GRUENBERG
Longshoremen carry signs and chant, October 1, 2024, outside
Features / 3 October 2024
3 October 2024
The ILA’s fight against wage stagnation and job-killing automation is gaining momentum and union solidarity as the Biden administration wisely resists pressure from the bosses to force strikers back to work, writes MARK GRUENBERG
Zebby, owned by Genevieve Moss from Derbyshire, is announced
Features / 12 April 2024
12 April 2024
Employees at Texas shelter Pets Alive joined forces with the Machinists union, seeking better conditions for both themselves and the animals they passionately care for, reports MARK GRUENBERG
Similar stories
(Right to left) Service Employees International Union intern
Features / 11 January 2025
11 January 2025
The looming Trump presidency has forced unions to rebuild their unity and strength, writes TONY BURKE, as the SEIU returns to the AFL-CIO, healing the 2005 rift over organising priorities and getting ready to fight the right together
Shoppers at the Walden Galleria in Buffalo, NY, stop by the
World / 20 December 2024
20 December 2024
ALL CHANGE? National Labor Relations Board HQ in Washington
Features / 15 November 2024
15 November 2024
Too few trade unionists voted for Kamala Harris to make a difference. TONY BURKE provides an explanation
TUC Congress 2024 / 10 September 2024
10 September 2024
Speaking to Elizabeth Short, SARAH WOOLLEY explains her union’s push for anonymous harassment reporting, an end to NDAs that protect abusive managers in food giants like McDonald’s — and why climate change is a baker’s issue