Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
Scottish politics: a cycle of goading and blame
MATT KERR argues that endless constitutional squabbles and feigned outrage over symbolic slights distract from real issues, as both SNP and opposition parties shirk responsibility for using the powers they already have

AT school, I got into a few scrapes.
 
If you’ve got a temper — and boy did I — trouble is directed your way, and usually with the same person. Things start with some tiny issue, and others notice. They’d form an audience encouraging both of us idiots to lob words at one another.
 
A nudge to the ribs.
 
“Are you takin’ that aff him, aye? I wouldnae,” a voice in my ear would say.
 
Across the way, my opponent was getting the same message; an appeal to the synthetic pride they draped over us that couldn’t be resisted.
 
Sooner or later, to chants of “fight, fight, fight,” fists would fly before we were carted off by a teacher.
 
The war ended when our exasperated teacher ditched detention for “community service.” We helped the janitor out, shovelling a bit of coal and cleaning the playground, and found ourselves becoming firm friends, uniting in work and in revulsion at the people who’d goaded us into it all in the first place.
 
Going about my business the other day, the interweb crashed in to tell me I was being ignored, sidelined, even “snubbed” by the Prime Minister.
 
On this occasion, though, I shouldn’t take it too personally, but instead feel aggrieved on behalf of the city of Glasgow, nay, the whole ancient nation of Scotland, because someone didn’t get invited to a committee.
 
Sir Keir held his first nation and regions summit in Edinburgh on Friday. The leaders of devolved administrations across Britain were all there, along with metro mayors representing selected English regions.
 
But where was Glasgow? Why didn’t the city’s council leader Susan Aitken get an invite? Oh, the humanity!
 
Aitken invited us all to be sad because she didn’t get to sit with the Prime Minister to talk about a range of subjects the respective officers and civil servants have already agreed on.
 
There was a bit of push-back on this matter, of course. Some pointed out that Glasgow City Council was not a city region, in fact, it continues to struggle on, unlike almost any other city on Earth, without the tax base of its suburbs.

The appalling suggestion that the solution was the Scottish government creating metro mayors here was even wheeled out — as ever, an answer wandering forlornly in search of a question.
 
But, we hear in reply, does that mean Scotland is being put on a par with Peterborough at these meetings? I think I’m supposed to be upset by that.
 
In all candour, I couldn’t care less. It’s just the usual nonsense which has clogged up what passes for politics in Scotland for what seems like an eternity.
 
If we are invited to be upset by an alleged underrepresentation at a talking shop, then perhaps the First Minister John Swinney, who has more powers at the disposal of his government than any devolved administration in Britain, could ask some friends over — as the host I’m sure it would be hard for such a request to be refused.
 
For the political classes in Scotland though, such an act would be too radical a gesture. Better by far to wallow in self-pity and the implication the world is out to get us, and all before a drink has even been taken.
 
After all, what better way to disempower a populace than have leaders whine in perpetuity on their own lack of power?
 
As the Labour government prepares its first austerity Budget since its last one 15 years ago, the tidal waves of demands for resources from cash-starved services are well under way, and rightly so.

Among them of course, the Scottish government has made its pitch, calling on Rachel Reeves to scrap the disgusting two-child benefits cap, the bedroom tax and ramp up NHS spending to the tune of £16 billion a year. These demands seem reasonable to me, in fact, if anything, they are too reasonable.
 
If those demands are met, the Scottish government would be released from having to spend cash mitigating slashed benefits and have another £1.6bn in Barnett consequentials to spend on the NHS, the SNP’s Westminster health spokesman Seamus Logan told us this week. I hope he gets his wish, I sincerely do.
 
What’s not to like?
 
Well, for a party that has made an art form out of pointing out the apparent bullying and controlling behaviour of “Westminster,” it is to rest an argument for more cash explicitly connecting health spending north and south of the border.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Aw That / 18 January 2025
18 January 2025
Mismanagement, privatisation and EU rules have strangled vital ferry services, leaving Scotland’s island communities stranded and the once-bustling ports of my youth in what feels like terminal decline, laments MATT KERR
Aw That / 21 December 2024
21 December 2024
Through hospital windows and news bulletins, personal loss opens a window onto the world’s wider suffering as the season, and the year itself, reminds us all why class solidarity matters now more than ever, writes MATT KERR
Aw That / 7 December 2024
7 December 2024
While farmers win support against inheritance tax changes, refinery workers seeking to save their jobs and community face deafening silence from Holyrood, writes MATT KERR
Aw That / 5 October 2024
5 October 2024
The closure of Edinburgh’s working-class People’s Story Museum contrasts sharply with lavish funding for aristocratic heritage sites. No-one will fight for our history — or our future — but us, writes MATT KERR
Similar stories
Aw That / 7 December 2024
7 December 2024
While farmers win support against inheritance tax changes, refinery workers seeking to save their jobs and community face deafening silence from Holyrood, writes MATT KERR
Aw That / 5 October 2024
5 October 2024
The closure of Edinburgh’s working-class People’s Story Museum contrasts sharply with lavish funding for aristocratic heritage sites. No-one will fight for our history — or our future — but us, writes MATT KERR
Features / 1 October 2024
1 October 2024
Unwanted, imposed Tory interventions on Scotland fuelled demands for devolution, and today Labour risks repeating past mistakes if Ian Murray seeks to bypass Holyrood on spending, warns PAULINE BRYAN
Opinion / 16 April 2024
16 April 2024
After Keir Starmer has made his politics plain for all to see, CHRIS STEPHENS MP argues that the SNP is now the more progressive party on the NHS, geopolitics, nuclear weapons and workers’ rights