Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Scottish government’s plans are a ‘failed opportunity’ to transform the economy
Socialist Labour MSP Mercedes Villalba says ‘failure is illustrated by the fact they’ve abandoned their key pledges’
The main chamber of the Scottish Parliament, Edinburgh

A SOCIALIST Labour MSP has described the Scottish government’s legislative plans for the year as a “failed opportunity” to transform the economy.

North East Scotland politician Mercedes Villalba said the programme for government, unveiled earlier this week by First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, will struggle to tackle the climate emergency, end inequality and shift economic power into Scottish communities. 

Senior trade unionists in Scotland have raised issues with the SNP’s strategy to fight the climate emergency and support workers, with the STUC saying proposals on green investments were “not credible” and criticising its response to the Just Transition Commission’s recommendations. 

Ms Villalba has now warned that Scotland could be left reliant on overseas energy production and manufacturing, with the government failing to deliver on its promise to create 130,000 green jobs and develop a green industrial base. 

The MSP argued the country will now be dependent on turbine imports from Europe to drive the shift to renewable energy, with a key pledge to create a publicly owned energy company in Scotland also being abandoned this week. 

With Scotland having already lost industrial assets such as BiFab and the Caley railworks, Ms Villalba condemned ministers’ continued tinkering around the edges.

She said: “We have an economy built on declining public services, rising levels of inequality, an ever-shrinking manufacturing base and increasingly insecure work.

“Their failure is illustrated by the fact they’ve abandoned their key pledge to introduce a new publicly owned energy company, leaving consumers at the mercy of market forces and Scotland without a driving force for investment in green energy and technologies.”

The Scottish government was approached for comment. 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Scottish Health Secretary Humza Yousaf
Britain / 9 January 2022
9 January 2022
It is ‘unfathomable’ that staff are having to keep doors and windows open and ask pupils to layer up for a second winter, Scottish Teachers for Positive Change and Wellbeing says
Similar stories
A bus under construction at the Alexander Dennis bus manufacturers in Falkirk
Voices of Scotland / 17 June 2025
17 June 2025

As bus builder Alexander Dennis threatens Falkirk closure and Grangemouth faces ruthless shutdown by tax exile Jim Ratcliffe, RICHARD LEONARD MSP warns that global corporations must be resisted by a bold industrial strategy based on public ownership

Climate activists from Greenpeace and Uplift during a demons
Voices of Scotland / 4 February 2025
4 February 2025
There is little benefit coming to Scotland or the wider UK from projects like Rosebank or Jackdaw – or indeed renewables – as profits are siphoned out of the country by foreign companies, writes PAULINE BRYAN
Protesters from the Edinburgh Climate Coalition outside the
Britain / 10 October 2024
10 October 2024