Railways need full return to public ownership

DEFENDERS of the Starmer government on the left habitually point to its intention to renationalise the railways as an earnest of its radicalism amid so many counter-indicators.
It is not a claim that stands up to much scrutiny. The more details emerge, the less Labour’s plans look anything like the integrated publicly owned railway the country needs.
As is well known, the Tories did not just privatise the network, they shattered it into hundreds of fragments, separating track from train operation, maintenance from both and train ownership from everyone else.
More from this author

ANDREW MURRAY casts an eye over past upheavals and asks whether the left can find a fire escape before the world goes up in flames

But Business Secretary downplays prospect of full nationalisation and declines to extend emergency assistance to Port Talbot or Grangemouth

Meanwhile, Labour government toughens rhetoric against the genocide, but stops short of making any changes in policy or practical support for Israel