Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
No love lost in this old v new Labour slug-fest

THIS latest play from political playwright James Graham plots the career of Labour MP David Lyons.

An entertaining romp through Labour’s recent history, it highlights the party’s difficulties through the lens of one constituency office in Nottingham where Lyons (Martin Freeman), supported by his corporate lawyer wife Elizabeth (Rachael Stirling), has been in office since 1990.

Set throughout in the office, it opens as he is about to lose the previously safe seat in last June’s election. A ruminating Lyons pictures himself becoming the Michael Portillo or Ed Balls of election night and declares that he’d better polish up his paso doble.

Lyons is a Blairite, while his agent and constituency manager Jean Whittaker (Tamsin Greig) is “old” labour. Typical of the ongoing barbed discourse is the scene where Lyons come out as a social democrat to the self-professed “democratic socialist” Whittaker and political wannabe Margot Midler (Susan Wokoma). The latter, in response to an SNP reference, declares that she would like to be a “national socialist.”

The personal and political relationship which ebbs and flows between Lyons and Whittaker typifies the constant tension between Labour “new” and “old” — the desire to win at all costs versus the need to be true to socialist principles.

And Lyons’s election defeat could be seen as marking the end of new Labour and the beginning of the Corbyn ascendancy — though this is only nodded at as the MP concedes that the future is Whittaker. Had Corbyn lost the election badly, the play’s conclusion may have been a little different.

Directed by Jeremy Herrin, this is a most enjoyable play. It’s brilliantly acted by Freeman and Greig, and the use of a screen at the rear of the stage providing a commentary on political events over the years provides a good background context to the narrative.

But at three hours it’s overlong and, sitcom-like, maybe plays too hard for laughs — the satirical edge is not as sharp as it might be. Another entertaining political drama from Graham, though to date he lacks the cutting edge of a David Hare.

Runs until December 2, box office: noelcowardtheatre.co.uk

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
SUPPING WITH THE DEVIL: Stanley Townsend (Mr Parks), Ivanno
Theatre review / 21 March 2025
21 March 2025
PAUL DONOVAN applauds a timely play that explores the resonances of McCarthyite nationalism in today’s US
Newcastle United's Bruno Guimaraes after the Premier League
Men's Football / 12 March 2025
12 March 2025
Men’s football / 16 February 2025
16 February 2025
SEEING EYE TO EYE: US President Meeting with Pope John Paul
Book Review / 13 February 2025
13 February 2025
PAUL DONOVAN is fascinated by an account of the long history of Catholic Church’s involvement in espionage
Similar stories
Jasmine Blackorow (Miss Bauer) and Michael Aloni (Art) in Da
Theatre Review / 26 September 2024
26 September 2024
MARY CONWAY feels the contemporary resonance of a new play set amid the manic and self-destructive patriotism of the McCarthy era
The cast of School for Scandal
Theatre Review / 10 July 2024
10 July 2024
GORDON PARSONS relishes a fast moving production of Sheridan’s comic masterpiece
Reform UK Leader Nigel Farage speaking during a BBC Question
Features / 4 July 2024
4 July 2024
BEN CHACKO says a stronger Morning Star would counter the corrosive influence of press barons on our political culture
CLASS FIGHTER: Tosh McDonald is seeking Doncaster Central’
Features / 29 June 2024
29 June 2024
Former president of Aslef, the train drivers’ union, TOSH McDONALD is the Workers Party candidate for Doncaster Central constituency on July 4. He talks to Morning Star northern reporter Peter Lazenby