Skip to main content
Kushner’s shame: how Gaza defeated the US stratagem, again
Biden’s laughably inadequate political ‘deals’ face surging global solidarity: China defends our right to armed struggle, and even Europe condemns Israel's war crimes. We are winning support like never before, writes RAMZY BAROUD
Jared Kushner listens as Donald Trump holds a breakfast meeting with Nato Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg at Winfield House, the residence of the Ambassador of the United States of America to the UK, in Regent's Park, London, December 3, 2019

JARED KUSHNER, a former US official whose relationship to power is that he married the wealthy daughter of a man who was later to become the US president, once attempted to teach Palestinians how to handle their own struggle for freedom.
 
In 2020, he advised Palestinians to stop “doing terrorism,” summing up the Palestinian problem in the claim that “five million Palestinians are (...) trapped because of bad leadership,” not the Israeli occupation or US support for Israel.
 
The inexperienced politician, who once bragged about reading 25 books on the Middle East, presented Palestinians with the same cliched rhetoric already offered to them by other ill-intentioned self-imposed “peacemakers.”
 
Palestinians “have a perfect track record of missing opportunities,” he said, rehashing the condescending language once used by Israel’s former minister of foreign affairs Abba Eban: “If they screw this up, I think that they will have a very hard time looking the international community in the face, saying they are victims.”
 
But why bring up Kushner now? Every few years, the US, at the behest of Israel, peddles such ideas that the Palestinian cause is finished, that solidarity with the Palestinian people is dead and that the Palestinian people and their leadership should accept whatever political or financial crumbs are thrown their way, courtesy of Washington, Tel Aviv and a few of their Western allies.
 
Yet every few years, the Palestinian people prove them wrong; that despite all the pressures — arm-twisting, sanctions, sieges, and relentless violence — they remain strong and not the victims they are ignorantly dubbed by Kushner.
 
What Kushner may not know is that there is a critical difference between victim and victimhood. While Palestinians cannot control their victimisation, since it is imposed on them from an outside force, Israel — generously financed by the US — they do not seek to be victims.
 
Indeed, victimhood is a different issue. It is the state of perceiving oneself as a perpetual victim, with no aspirations, and no agency.
 
While it is true that the ongoing Israeli genocide in Gaza is one of the greatest crimes of mass killings and ethnic cleansing in modern history, it is also true that no nation, in recent decades, has fought back as ferociously as the Palestinians. This is hardly the behaviour of a victim.
 
The Joe Biden administration, like every other US administration, has talked down to Palestinians, declaring them foolish for not accepting political deals that would fail to guarantee them the most basic of their long-denied rights.

While Palestinians sought total and unconditional freedom, Camp David (1979), the Oslo Accords (1993), the Road Map (2004), and every other “offer” before, during or after were political attempts at prolonging the Israeli occupation and denying the rights of the Palestinians. Kushner’s was not the exception.
 
All of these previous US “peace proposals” were obviously unfair, as they were to Israel’s advantage and were designed entirely independently from international and humanitarian laws. All of these pro-Israel proposals have failed, not due to the international community’s ability to challenge Washington, but due to the tenacity of the Palestinian people.
 
Palestinians defeated the US agenda, but that was not enough to clinch their own freedom, simply because they were in this difficult battle alone.
 
Solidarity with the Palestinian people has always been one of the pillars of all international solidarity movements worldwide for decades. The phrase “free Palestine” has been written on countless walls, in every language, in every city, town, or working-class neighbourhood.

Still, that solidarity was not enough to turn the tide, to achieve the coveted paradigm shift or to reach the critical mass needed to globalise the struggle for the freedom of the Palestinians the way that the struggle to end South Africa’s apartheid imposed itself as a moral necessity on the whole world.
 
There should be no illusions that the anti-apartheid struggle of South Africa and the struggle for Palestinian freedom are identical. Back then, the global geopolitical shift made it difficult for Pretoria to maintain its racial segregation regime. Moreover, the power of that racist government, if compared to that of Israel and its backers, is minuscule.
 
Washington sees Israel as an integral part of the US global influence. For US politicians, Israel is a domestic and not simply a foreign policy issue.

Donate to the Fighting Fund
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
US President Donald Trump (right) shakes the hand of Israel'
Features / 15 April 2025
15 April 2025
Once able to defy a US president before Congress, Netanyahu now finds himself weakened by military setbacks and facing a populist Trump who may yet put ‘America first’ instead of Israel, writes RAMZY BAROUD
BREAKING POINT: Israelis take part in a protest against Prim
Features / 10 April 2025
10 April 2025
Netanyahu’s failed attempt to replace Shin Bet’s chief violates longstanding Israeli political taboos, as the apartheid state’s internal power struggle spirals to a new level of crisis while Gaza burns, writes RAMZY BAROUD
Buildings destroyed during the Israeli air and ground offens
Features / 4 March 2025
4 March 2025
Israel’s crimes in Gaza have forced a reckoning with international law’s selective application as Western nations sanction ICC prosecutors and attack UN officials who demand accountability, writes RAMZY BAROUD
Residents of the al-Far’a Camp, West Bank, evacuate their
Features / 10 February 2025
10 February 2025
Will 2025 be a year of combat for Israel, as promised by the new IDF chief of staff, wonders RAMZY BAROUD
Similar stories
Displaced Palestinians return to their destroyed homes in th
Features / 5 February 2025
5 February 2025
RAMZY BAROUD explains why, despite horrific losses and destruction, many Palestinians talk of return to their homes as a victory
Activists protest outside the Foreign, Commonwealth, and Dev
Features / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
RAMZY BAROUD offers a penetrating, if blunt, insight on the changing nature and role of international solidarity for Palestine
SETTLER VIOLENCE: Mourners in the West Bank city of Bethlehe
Features / 5 September 2024
5 September 2024
RAMZY BAROUD exposes the growing rift between Israel’s religious zealots and its security establishment, as Kahanist ideology and growing settler violence begin to destabilise the delicate balance of the occupation regime
LIVES REDUCED TO TATTERS: Displaced Palestinians arrive in c
Features / 10 May 2024
10 May 2024
It is clear now beyond any doubt that Israel aims to destroy Gaza and annex the West Bank. As the Palestinian resistance has shown this is not possible, will the West start listening to the Palestinian people, asks RAMZY BAROUD