Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
Gaza: what can Scotland do?
The political positions here are better than Westminster on the massacre going on in Palestine, but we can and must do more, explains CAROL MOCHAN

IN Scotland, like much of the rest of the world, the national conversation has recently been dominated by the absolute horror we have seen in Israel and Palestine since October 7.
 
I have added my voice to those who immediately condemned the slaughter committed by Hamas and have been very clear subsequently that the retaliation by Israel has gone well beyond any notion of self-defence. What we are seeing is an attempt to crush Gaza and completely decimate the already highly precarious society they possessed.
 
We are witnessing a massacre live on our television screens and the British government are simply waving it through while providing financial and military aid to those dropping unimaginable amounts of incendiary devices on homes, universities, and even hospitals.
 
Who does this conflict serve? We are destabilising the world and giving succour to extremists. Have we learned nothing from the mistakes of Afghanistan and Iraq?
 
Let us be clear, Palestinians have for many years been living in what amounts to an open-air prison. They have very limited freedoms and those they have are often entirely at the behest of Israel — which goes entirely against the Oslo Accords agreed back in the 1990s that committed both sides to Palestinian self-determination.
 
Sadly, however, these concerns have not been reflected in the Scottish Parliament or the media where far too much coverage and business seem to be about avoiding this very important issue rather than boldly standing for peace and against war, or it solely focuses on the legitimacy or lack thereof when referring to demonstrations. This is hardly the key issue.
 
Thankfully, despite this lack of official condemnation, the leaders of every party other than the Scottish Conservatives have come out in favour of a ceasefire. This sets Scotland apart from Britain’s political structure and highlights one of many strengths of devolution.
 
Shockingly the First Minister himself had relatives in Gaza until very recently and Scots saw first-hand a real-life connection to the conflict.

This was an important factor in bringing the conflict closer to home and I am glad that his relatives have now been able to leave Gaza during the bombardment — we can only hope that they will be able to return to something resembling a home. I fear for many families it will be a forlorn hope.
 
Given my brief within the Scottish Parliamentary Labour Party, I have given a considerable amount of my concern to the plight of women, and I am deeply concerned at the extremely vulnerable position pregnant women are finding themselves in.

It is estimated that 50,000 pregnant women are trapped in Gaza, and 5,000 are due to give birth in the next month. Without clean water, medicine, and humanitarian aid, these women and their babies will be at risk which is absolutely devastating.

I will continue to fully back the International Confederation of Midwives call for governments to demand the protection of the lives of pregnant women and their children and to open humanitarian corridors to allow medical aid to reach them immediately. I have raised this within the party and will continue to raise it at every opportunity.
 
Some may believe that what is taking place in Palestine has received more than enough attention. I would argue the opposite. People need to truly understand the horror that is taking place and the key historical role our country played in bringing these circumstances to reality.
 
I may not have signed the declarations, or supported the occupations that began so many years ago — but I certainly feel a responsibility to the people of Palestine — and I think given all of the passionate responses we have seen on the streets of Scotland over recent weeks it is clear the public feel that way too.
 
Given this, it seems to me to be an untenable position for Keir Starmer to continue to avoid calling for a ceasefire when the international community clearly has majority agreement on this issue. To fail to condemn Israel is unconscionable, just as it would have been unconscionable not to condemn Hamas following the attacks in the south of Israel.
 
The collective punishment of an entire people is clearly a war crime under international law, yet what is a law worth if it is not enforced? Statements from the UN telling Israel to behave may appear to be impactful on paper, but the bombs still rain down.
 
We need to firmly put pressure on Britain, the US, and any other country that continues to support this abomination. We must keep the pressure on and must continue to demand a ceasefire.

Carol Mochan is Scottish Labour MSP for South Scotland — follow her on Twitter @CMochan.

Ad slot F - article bottom
More from this author
Voices of Scotland / 25 June 2024
25 June 2024
As the Tories wither and the SNP’s independence dream fades, CAROL MOCHAN MSP urges voters to reject nationalist complacency and embrace a transformative Labour government that could tackle poverty and climate change head-on
Features / 17 February 2024
17 February 2024
As Scottish Labour conference takes place in Glasgow, CAROL MOCHAN MSP sees some specific challenges facing the party north of the border
Features / 8 May 2023
8 May 2023
The new First Minister may have inherited a mess not of his making, but that only compounds his incredibly weak commitment to progressive reform and generally poor helmsmanship, writes CAROL MOCHAN MSP
Voices of Scotland / 3 October 2022
3 October 2022
CAROL MOCHAN argues that a new report from the Scottish Parliament’s health, social care and sport committee that reveals endemic and deepening poverty also demonstrates that the SNP are still failing to act on inequality
Similar stories
Features / 1 June 2024
1 June 2024
JOHNNIE HUNTER introduces the 12 priorities which will be taken to voters across the country by Communist Party candidates running in July’s general election
Opinion / 16 April 2024
16 April 2024
After Keir Starmer has made his politics plain for all to see, CHRIS STEPHENS MP argues that the SNP is now the more progressive party on the NHS, geopolitics, nuclear weapons and workers’ rights
Features / 22 January 2024
22 January 2024
URI WELTMANN reports on the biggest demonstration since the beginning of the war on Gaza that defied the police and brought together all those calling for a ceasefire on the streets of Tel-Aviv
Voices of Scotland / 12 December 2023
12 December 2023
We need genuine freedom of information legislation in Scotland to hold our government and all public bodies accountable, writes KATY CLARK MSP, introducing a new campaign