Skip to main content
Fight Farage, but don’t support Swinney’s ‘unpopular front’

COLL McCAIL rejects the Scottish Establishment’s attempt at an ‘elite lockout’ of Reform UK and says the unions should be wary of co-option by their class enemies in Holyrood just to keep one set of austerity-mongers in power instead of Reform UK

SOMETHING CHANGED: Nigel Farage, seen here chased through the streets of Edinburgh in 2013, now commands the support of some 10,000 Scots

LAST Friday morning, Glasgow City Councillor Thomas Kerr took to social media to announce that, following a recent surge in recruitment, Reform UK now has more than 10,000 members in Scotland. If Kerr, a recent Tory defector, is correct, Nigel Farage’s party is now the country’s third-largest — and may yet surpass Scottish Labour.

The results of a Fife council by-election later that day sounded further alarm bells for Anas Sarwar and his party. In Glenrothes, Scottish Labour — already well beaten by the SNP — narrowly avoided ceding second place to Reform UK by a margin of just 3 per cent. This is the latest in a string of local by-elections across the country at which similar results have been recorded.

Kerr attributed his party’s recent momentum to the fallout from the Scottish government’s anti-far-right summit, which took place last Wednesday. In the gilded environs of Glasgow’s Merchant House, the First Minister united the great and the good of civic Scotland to discuss “locking” Reform UK out of Holyrood after next May’s Scottish election.

The leaders of Scotland’s major political parties, barring the Conservatives, all attended. Together, they agreed to recommit to upholding the values of “participation and openness,” “the sharing of power,” “accountability,” and “equal opportunity.”

The problem, of course, is that John Swinney’s unpopular front lacks even the pretence of legitimacy. Indeed, the stunt was so poorly executed that, within 24 hours of its conclusion, the respective MSPs had returned to Holyrood to tear lumps out of one another at First Minister’s Questions.

After all, what can politicians who routinely use public consultation as a means of putting radical policy proposals out to pasture tell the Scottish public about “participation?” What can Swinney, whose party has spent the last four years under police investigation for fraud, tell us about “openness?” What can the Scottish government, for who centralisation has long been a key organising principle, teach the electorate about “the sharing of power?”

What can any of Scotland’s politicians know of “accountability” for as long as they remain content to entrust swathes of our economy to the control of asset managers? What lectures can Anas Sarwar give on “equal opportunity” while he remains resolute in his support of the British government’s £5 billion welfare raid?

This is not about purity politics — far from it. My point is simply to emphasise that Swinney’s summit to stop Reform UK risks doing exactly the opposite. The event serves only to legitimise Farage’s false claim that his party represents the only alternative to a moribund political establishment, so much so that this formerly disparate bunch are teaming up to stop it.

As this article’s opening paragraph sought to convey, Reform UK represents a clear and present threat in Scotland. However, the success of any challenge to Farage’s radical right-wing agenda will depend on its ability to face down the actors who have fostered his rise. Instead, unable to look themselves in the mirror, last Wednesday, Scotland’s politicians put their fingers in their ears and shut the door behind them.

Those who disagree with the thrust of this column may argue that Swinney’s summit was called in the best traditions of the devolved settlement. It was, after all, a similarly broad front which made up the Scottish Constitutional Convention and led the campaign for home rule more than 25 years ago. The problem, however, is that it is not 1999. It’s 2025.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Coins and Scottish bank notes
Features / 19 April 2025
19 April 2025
From Labour MPs obsessing over Easter egg shapes to SNP ministers celebrating pay rises while marking zoo animals’ arrivals, Scottish politics is really deteriorating, says COLL McCAIL
Scottish Greens co-leader Lorna Slater addresses members, Ma
Features / 30 October 2024
30 October 2024
COLL MCCAIL reveals how party members rebelled against the current leadership’s attempts to block democratic debate on opposing SNP budget cuts at their Greenock conference
Flames and smoke rise from an Israeli airstrike in Dahiyeh,
Voices of Scotland / 8 October 2024
8 October 2024
The British government actively supports Israel’s escalating violence across the Middle East through arms sales, military assistance, and diplomatic cover, writes COLL McCAIL
Features / 17 September 2024
17 September 2024
The independence referendum’s youthful energy has dissipated, leaving Holyrood disconnected from voters as the constitutional question fades and Labour gains ground from a stagnant SNP, writes COLL MCCAIL
Similar stories
First Minister of Scotland John Swinney during a press conference in Bute House, Edinburgh, April 14, 2025
Britain / 21 April 2025
21 April 2025
First Minister of Scotland John Swinney speaks during a pres
Britain / 14 March 2025
14 March 2025
Kate Forbes and newly appointed First Minister of Scotland J
Britain / 9 May 2024
9 May 2024