Just as German Social Democrats joined the Nazis in singing Deutschland Uber Alles, ANDREW MURRAY observes how Starmer tries to out-Farage Farage with anti-migrant policies — but evidence shows Reform voters come from Tories, not Labour, making this ploy morally bankrupt and politically pointless
The Starmer era: a study in failure
Labour now faces three options — a liberal alliance with the Greens and Lib Dems, a leadership challenge that may well not go to the left — or gathering together the remaining socialist forces in the party to fight for policies, writes ANDREW MURRAY

THREE PER CENT. Just 3 per cent.
Labour’s nationally projected share of the vote based on the local election results this month was 35 per cent.
That is a mere 3 per cent more than it secured in the 2019 general election and 5 per cent less than it won under Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership in 2017.
More from this author

Just as German Social Democrats joined the Nazis in singing Deutschland Uber Alles, ANDREW MURRAY observes how Starmer tries to out-Farage Farage with anti-migrant policies — but evidence shows Reform voters come from Tories, not Labour, making this ploy morally bankrupt and politically pointless