Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Domestic pyrotechnics
MATTHEW HAWKINS is drawn into the everyday lives of women and girls in Muslim communities in southern India
MUSLIM WOMEN'S RIGHTS: A mural from the Shaheen Bagh protests by mostly Muslim women against the BJP's discriminatory Citizen Amendment Act, police brutality, poverty, unemployment and women's safety, February 2020

Heart Lamp
Banu Mushtaq, And Other Stories, £14.99

IN Heart Lamp: Selected Stories, matters marinate or smoulder. Readers get to pore over paragraphs while issues ignite. 

Amid her precise environments, and their host of vivid social-class enmity/familial powerplay, writer Banu Mushtaq delineates volatile occurrence with trustworthy control. Her succinct flair in sketching distinct three-dimensional allies and adversaries sets her arena for pivotal realisation and outcome. I’m put in mind of the sparking of domestic pyrotechnics, blue touchpaper and all.

In translation by Deepa Bhasthi, many choice Kannada words persist. These are never italicised. The beauty of this choice means not only that the music of given names; details and condition of dress; inventories of foods – and reference to who’s doing the cooking – each remain powerfully intact. Original words are also used where legal forces and devices of tradition come into play and this all feels right, in recognition of documentary authenticity and cultural nuance. English language readers will sense and respect complex entities (Sharia, for example) while protagonists — many of them adorable against the odds — maintain voices of credible immediacy.

Where I was flipping straight from the end of one tale into the beginning of the next in sequence, the reiteration of themes brought awareness of an activist’s writerly devices and agenda. Culture abounds here, as elevated ritual and psychic truth, whereas the material application of cultural notions cannot but lapse into mechanistic tradition, with compelled female roles bearing the brunt. Here is a choreography of thwarted aspirations, forced marriages, servitude, crises of the womb, precarious retainers, and elder marginalisation. There’s also a curiously inevitable hollow meanness in women who embrace ostentatious marital wealth. 

Each plot hinges on the energy of a capricious self-serving impulse. There’s tug-of-war around vital home and hearth and no shortage of deep shame. I found the scenarios encouraged guess-the-culprit, and I began to think how well the material would serialise on our screens.

Where I read with more respite, I could register one story’s cadence with a full sob then later embark on another, with its gut punch or sudden radiance. I became less conscious of writerly calculation, sensing instead an author’s copious immersion and how fully this honours fragile experience in its spontaneous turn.

Morning Star Conference - Race, Sex & Class
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
dance
Follow the Movement / 19 May 2025
19 May 2025

MATTHEW HAWKINS gives us a sense of what to expect from Glasgow’s International Dance festival

dance
Dance / 9 May 2025
9 May 2025

MATTHEW HAWKINS surveys the upcoming programme of contemporary dance in Glasgow, and picks some highlights

SENSUAL ENLIGHTENMENT: Teige Bisnought and Dylan Springer in
Follow the Movement / 18 March 2025
18 March 2025
MATTHEW HAWKINS appreciates an interpretation in dance of James Baldwin’s landmark novel of doomed homosexual desire
Fergus Greer, (L) Leigh Bowery Session 1 Look 2 1988; (R) Le
Follow the movement / 18 February 2025
18 February 2025
MATTHEW HAWKINS pays tribute to the performance artist and costumier, Leigh Bowery
Similar stories
dance
Follow the Movement / 19 May 2025
19 May 2025

MATTHEW HAWKINS gives us a sense of what to expect from Glasgow’s International Dance festival

SENSUAL ENLIGHTENMENT: Teige Bisnought and Dylan Springer in
Follow the Movement / 18 March 2025
18 March 2025
MATTHEW HAWKINS appreciates an interpretation in dance of James Baldwin’s landmark novel of doomed homosexual desire
MAKING THE BEST OF REJECTION: Rupert Everett at Munich Filmf
Books / 25 February 2025
25 February 2025
MATTHEW HAWKINS sees past the purple prose to themes of rejection and ageing in the autobiographical fiction of Rupert Everett
Book Review / 13 August 2024
13 August 2024
ANDY HEDGECOCK recommends a collection of folk tales, each of which is dazzling flash of human experience, natural or supernatural