Skip to main content
Compassion or cost-cutting? The slippery slope of assisted dying
Labour must fight to ensure any new laws do not become tools for social cleansing of the poor and disabled, argues JOHN McINALLY, as some begin considering NHS savings that could come at the cost of working-class lives
Campaigners against voluntary euthanasia

AS THE government considers the issue of assisted dying with a view to legislation, the question of who frames the debate, and how, should be of real concern for working-class people and the labour and trade union movement, which cannot afford to be a bystander in the discussion.

The case for legalising assisted dying will be championed by the liberal political class and personalities as a “human right,” a matter of personal autonomy and “choice,” even a social justice issue and a progressive moral principle, elevated above and distinct from other factors, including class interest.

When liberals demand a “human right” it invariably means the moral right of the individual abstracted above that of the collective, with scant regard or consideration of the potential consequences for wider society, and certainly not of the working class.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Morning Star call for advertising
More from this author
MAJOR CONCERNS: Campaigners protest in Westminster ahead of
Features / 28 November 2024
28 November 2024
JOHN McINALLY argues trade unions and socialists must demand properly funded healthcare instead of a change that, combined with neoliberal capitalism, will see working-class people pushed towards suicide
Campaigners in support of voluntary euthanasia protest outsi
Features / 24 September 2024
24 September 2024
JOHN McINALLY warns that Labour’s hasty push for legislation ignores the international evidence of expanding eligibility criteria, potentially normalising the ‘social murder’ of working-class people under the guise of compassion
Anti-auserity march
Features / 14 July 2024
14 July 2024
JOHN McINALLY calls for militant trade unionism and overt socialist politics to counter the new government’s pro-capitalist agenda and a looming authoritarian turn that threatens to muzzle working-class resistance
General secretary of the Public and Commercial Services (PCS
Features / 13 January 2024
13 January 2024
At the helm of Britain’s eighth-largest union for a quarter of a century, he is rightly seen as one of the most principled and effective class fighters of our times, writes JOHN McINALLY
Similar stories
MAJOR CONCERNS: Campaigners protest in Westminster ahead of
Features / 28 November 2024
28 November 2024
JOHN McINALLY argues trade unions and socialists must demand properly funded healthcare instead of a change that, combined with neoliberal capitalism, will see working-class people pushed towards suicide
LETHAL OBJECTION: Campaigners protest outside Parliament in
Features / 26 November 2024
26 November 2024
ANSELM ELDERGILL details the problems associated with the Assisted Dying Bill which has its second reading on Friday
Campaigners in support of voluntary euthanasia protest outsi
Features / 24 September 2024
24 September 2024
JOHN McINALLY warns that Labour’s hasty push for legislation ignores the international evidence of expanding eligibility criteria, potentially normalising the ‘social murder’ of working-class people under the guise of compassion