Skip to main content
Dream or Nightmare
Critique of communicating radical politics flies in the face of progressive reason
THE STRUGGLE CONTUINUES: ‘La beauté est dans la rue’ (Beauty is in the street) the Situationist slogan at the London 2018 demo against Trump and (left) as first designed by Atelier Populaire in Paris in 1968 [Central/main pic credit: Steve Bowbrick/Creative Commons]

ORIGINALLY published in 2007 as Dream, this polemic from Stephen Duncombe has been retitled to reflect the recent resurgence of ultra-conservative politics.

Fascinating but flimsily argued, it calls for a reassessment of progressive approaches to campaigning and persuading. Duncombe’s thesis is that the left tends to “uncritically privilege rationality, reason and self-revelatory truth,” while the right has shifted to a more successful approach based on improvisation, spectacle and “dreampolitik” — the creation of political fantasies — and it is argued that we live in an age of fantasy.

During the George W Bush administration, a presidential aide suggested the world was analysed by “the reality-based community” while reality was created and acted upon by conservatives. Duncombe believes the left is drifting into irrelevance due to our preference for “the solace of the known” and reverence for logical evidence.  

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
arday
BenchMarx / 21 August 2026
21 August 2026

ANGUS REID urges us to understand the persecution of Jason Arday from a political and historical perspective, and to see the victim in human terms

irrational
Books / 3 July 2026
3 July 2026

ANDY HEDGECOCK welcomes an entertaining, useful guide to the threats and promises of mathematical rationality

STEADFAST: Members of the Public and Commercial Services union (PCS) on the picket line outside HMRC in East Kilbride during a strike in the long-running civil service dispute over pay, jobs and conditions, May 2023
Features / 22 November 2025
22 November 2025

In part IV of a serialisation of his new book, JOHN McINALLY tells how austerity minister Francis Maude’s attempt to destroy the PCS Civil Service union totally backfired