Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Labour demands apology from CBI after privately admitting it exaggerated cost of Corbyn's nationalisation plans
Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn makes a speech at the Confederation of British Industry in November 2016

LABOUR has demanded an apology from the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) after it privately admitted to exaggerating the cost of Jeremy Corbyn’s nationalisation plans.

A leaked email exchange shows the big business lobby group conceded that its statistics published on Monday were incorrect.

The CBI had claimed that public ownership plans outlined in Labour’s 2017 manifesto would cost £196 billion in taxpayers’ money.

In response, a Labour figure asked the CBI why it thought the party would buy back trains from rail operators, which is not its policy.

A CBI representative then told Labour: “We have assumed the rolling stock would be bought into public ownership as the trains are currently owned by the private sector and therefore full-scale nationalisation of rail would require this.

“However, we recognise that this isn’t official Labour policy on nationalising the rail industry.”

However, the bosses’ club refused to divulge more details about its calculations, saying in the email exchange that their “members do not feel comfortable” explaining exactly where the £196bn figure came from.

Labour shadow transport secretary Andy McDonald demanded an apology from the CBI director Carolyn Fairbairn, saying: “The CBI’s shoddy research and shabby conduct does a great disservice to our political debate during the hugely challenging times through which we now live.

“At the very least, I would expect an apology from Carolyn Fairbairn over the distorted misrepresentations her organisation has sought to peddle.”

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell added that an apology “wouldn’t go amiss.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Britain / 27 February 2020
27 February 2020
Britain / 27 February 2020
27 February 2020
Britain / 26 February 2020
26 February 2020
Similar stories
Features / 19 April 2025
19 April 2025
British Steel has vindicated what the left has said all along — nationalisation of our key industries is common sense, and it’s the neoliberals who are now clearly the ideologically driven zealots, writes DIANE ABBOTT MP
A Thameslink train
Features / 13 September 2024
13 September 2024
SOLOMON HUGHES explains how rolling stock companies like Angel Trains will continue milking taxpayers for billions even after renationalisation, as Canadian pension funds and Texan oil billionaires cash in on our daily commutes