Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Alleged victim of trafficking wins right to full hearing
EXCLUSIVE by Sam Tobin at the High Court

A VIETNAMESE woman allegedly trafficked into Britain as a child was found by the Home Office to not be at risk of exploitation despite its own staff recommending that she be taken into care at the airport.

Lawyers for the 20-year-old, known only as V, said yesterday the Home Office had “perversely relied on the steps taken to remove [V] from real and immediate risk of harm” to justify its decision that there were no conclusive grounds to believe she was a victim of child trafficking.

Shu Shin Luh, representing V, said the Home Office was using the “protection of the victim from real and immediate risks of exploitation … [as] grounds for denying the victim further protection.”

She said that V’s father, who was “violent and abusive towards her,” had arranged for her to “attend a course in the UK” for which they had to pay more than £4,000 for tuition and an additional £2,000 a month for accommodation, even though she was to stay with her paternal uncle.

V arrived at Gatwick airport in December 2014, aged 17, and was immediately placed in emergency local authority care under Operation Newbridge, a joint operation by West Sussex County Council (WSCC) and Sussex Police, after a Border Force officer concluded there was a “strong likelihood” that V had been trafficked.

WSCC agreed, finding that there was a “risk that she would be exploited in the form of enforced labour, cannabis cultivation or prostitution” if allowed to live with her uncle.

V has since been in the protection of the council’s children’s services, but the Home Office claims that, because V “never came to any harm,” any concerns about her alleged trafficking are “speculative.”

Just after her arrival, the Home Office considered her to be a potential victim of trafficking but decided in September 2016 that she had not been trafficked, a decision upheld in November 2017 and again in January, as it was “incredible” that her father would agree to her leaving Vietnam.

But Ms Luh said an independent report by child-trafficking expert Christine Beddoe said the trafficking of Vietnamese children by their families is a “widely known pattern.”

Citing the National Crime Agency’s own figures, she pointed out that “Vietnamese children have consistently been the largest group of foreign national children” referred to the authorities as suspected victims of trafficking.

Judge Richard Clayton QC said V’s written case for a judicial review of the Home Office’s decision was “pretty persuasive” and granted permission for a full hearing.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
Britain / 17 June 2021
17 June 2021
All eight claimants say Labour acted unfairly by failing to close investigations or revoke their suspension or expulsion
Similar stories
BETTER LATE THAN NEVER: Roheez Khan, left, and Mustaq Ahmed,
Features / 15 March 2025
15 March 2025
ANN CZERNIK concludes her three-part series on the hidden scale of child sexual exploitation in Britain
CALLS FOR ACCOUNTABILITY: The Home Office is under pressure
Features / 8 March 2025
8 March 2025
Campaigners have been battling for an investigation into police failings in Keighley on child abuse for almost 25 years – but what is it about this West Yorkshire town that’s led to it becoming such a hub for grooming gangs? ANN CZERNIK investigates
Screen grab of Conservative party leader Kemi Badenoch speak
Britain / 8 January 2025
8 January 2025
Starmer and Badenoch claim to speak on behalf of the abused, yet both focus mainly on scoring points off each other