Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
‘Vacuous and costly’ Hogmanay needs a rethink, says councillor after event cancelled

AFTER weather warnings forced the cancellation of Edinburgh’s official Hogmanay celebrations, organisers face questions on its sustainability.

Calling off the fireworks display over the castle, the street party and concerts in Princes Street Gardens after predictions of 70mph winds, a spokesperson for Edinburgh’s Hogmanay said: “We know that this will be hugely disappointing to all hoping to celebrate Hogmanay in Edinburgh and that people travel from around the world to be here.”

Two of those travellers were Aditi Sahu and Neeraj Krishnan, who travelled from London planning their trip around the fireworks.

Mr Krishnan said: “We don’t really know what to do for new year.”

Ms Sahu added: “They should have had a plan B in place.

“At the last minute, you are not going to find anything good.

“Edinburgh is expensive.”

Calling on the council, which recently agreed a three-year deal with Unique Assembly to run the events, to change its approach and make the celebrations more sustainable, independent Edinburgh councillor Ross McKenzie told the Star: “The council could transfer that £812,000-a-year into putting on ceilidhs in communities across the city and tell tourists that if they want to go and experience a bit of Scottish Hogmanay, then here’s a list of 20 community centres where they’re having local events — go and enjoy it.” 

Slamming the official events as “middle class” and expensive, he added: “I feel really embarrassed when I see tourists come here for Hogmanay events because they are shit.

“We have the torchlight procession which last year would have cost a family of four over £100 to wait in a queue for two hours sold as ‘traditional.’

“We don’t have a traditional torchlight procession.

“It’s a made-up thing to sell tickets to tourists.

“It’s empty, it’s vacuous, it’s devoid of culture or tradition.”

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
(left to right) Scottish Labour deputy leader Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar and Davy Russell celebrate during a rally on Castle Street, Hamilton, after he was declared the winner for the Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election, June 6, 2025
Scotland / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025
Teachers from the Educational Institute of Scotland (EIS) union take part in a rally outside the constituency office of Education Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville in Dunfermline, Fife, during their strike action in dispute over pay, February 22, 2023
EIS Conference 2025 / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025
Teachers from the Educational Institute of Scotland (EIS) union take part in a rally outside the Tramway in Glasgow on day two of the strike action in a dispute over pay, March 1, 2023
Scotland / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025
Similar stories
NOT EVERYBODY’S CUP OF TEA: (Above) Nigel Farage, on a gen
Features / 4 January 2025
4 January 2025
Speak up for your community, for your class, build platforms for those who would be silenced, posits MATT KERR
Unite rep Graeme Smith (left) and Campaign organiser Jim Sla
Britain / 7 November 2024
7 November 2024
A firework display
Britain / 5 November 2024
5 November 2024
TOURIST TRAP: A view of the Edinburgh skyline. Housing press
Features / 27 August 2024
27 August 2024
After sustained campaigning by Living Rent, Edinburgh council is to introduce a visitor levy, with some of the money raised going towards council housing in the capital – a welcome step in a city under great pressure from an ever-expanding tourist industry, says KATHARINA BANDMANN