Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Books: Film After Film
Conflicted attempts to reshape reality in 'the American way'

Film After Film

by J Hoberman

(Verso Books, £16.99)

On the surface J Hoberman's new retrospective on 21st-century film seems a rather fractured affair, divided as it is between two different aspects of modern cinema.

Initially, Hoberman explores the impact of the digital revolution and asks whether the ongoing digital manipulation of the photographic image mark the loss of film's once celebrated ability to represent reality. The author deems popular franchises like The Matrix and Harry Potter films to in fact be "animated movies created from photographic material."

Yet as we drift away from the purity of the photographic image Hoberman also debates how digital cinema has found new ways to simulate reality, the "visceral realness" of computer-enhanced wounds in The Passion Of The Christ being the most alarming example of what, in his reasoned and contemplative prose, the author dubs the "new real."

But then the book abruptly transforms into a stinging and pleasingly wry retrospective of recent cinematic politics in the US.

The shifting tastes of audiences are chronicled in the wake of the World Trade Centre bombing and Hoberman demonstrates how films act as a barometer for public sentiment. Immediately after September 11 2001 studios shelved many violent action projects like Collateral Damage only to take them out of mothballs to cash in on an eruption of patriotism as the US military mobilised for vengeance.

Film After Film also examines how this is linked with the US government's unsettlingly close relationship with the film industry. Politicians use cinema as an ideological battleground, an example being Donald Rumsfeld not only describing the political thriller The Sum Of All Fears as the "ultimate advertisement for homeland security" but providing Pentagon support for its production too.

But it's also clear that the relationship of 21st-century politics with film isn't limited to the silver screen.

As Hoberman points out, while critiquing the jarringly fabricated world of Republican Party conventions, US conservatives have "perfected the art of making a movie in 'life.'"

While Film After Film's sudden change in subject and writing style might have rendered it structurally fractured, instead its two strands serve to subtly bolster one another.

This fresh, bold, witty and authoritative book reveals a medium still striving to recreate reality while still cynically being used to shape it.

Steve Richards

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
Keir Starmer
Editorial / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves speaks with the media at the Rolls-Royce factory in Derby, following the announcement from the Office for National Statistics that the UK economy grew by 0.7% between January and March, May 15, 2025
Editorial: / 15 May 2025
15 May 2025
Similar stories
Pic: Kharsohtun/CC
Books / 25 May 2025
25 May 2025

ANDY HEDGECOCK admires a critique of the penetration of our lives by digital media, but is disappointed that the underlying cause is avoided

American flags representing the 200,000 dead from COVID-19 p
Book Review / 25 March 2025
25 March 2025
SARAH TROTT explores short fictional slices of life in the American midwest from a middle-aged and mostly female perspective
Book Review / 25 March 2025
25 March 2025
ANDREW HEDGECOCK relishes visual storytelling with no respect for genres, movements or styles
CALVINO/POTOCKI/BORGES ASSOCIATIONS: Dancing House, Prague n
Books / 21 August 2024
21 August 2024
ANDY HEDGECOCK relishes a novel by a dazzling prose stylist and a subtle player of literary games