Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
Britain’s deadly migration crisis demands honesty, not hysteria

FOUR people died needlessly crossing the English Channel. It is halfway through the year and over 13,000 people who risked crossing this narrow stretch of water we call our own made it safely. But no-one really knows how many died.

The last government, and this one, mask the shared inhumanity of their approach to this with a self-serving narrative about the criminal gangs who profit from their monopoly in this inhuman trade.

But as any Establishment neoliberal economist will tell us, markets respond to demand. And as every Friday night cokehead knows, illegal market demand will be met by criminals.

So when the new Home Secretary says these four deaths are “truly awful” these words are devoid of human meaning if nothing in her power is done to put an end to this deadly trade and set up safe routes for refugees, asylum-seekers and migrants.

Now the neocolonial arrogance about sending people to Rwanda has ended, Britain needs to put the national discussion about immigration on a rational footing.

If this is not done the Farageiste farrago of nonsensical ideas about the normal modern-day flow of people to and fro will feed a reactionary underbelly of myths, and fuel a fascist revival.

These most malign participants in the lopsided national conversation about immigration make much of the flow of small boats bringing desperate people to Britain.

Most people “legally” arriving in Britain in the 12 months up to June last year were non-EU nationals (968,000), followed by EU citizens (129,000) and British (84,000).

While last year around just 29,000 people arrived in small boats, down from 46,000 in 2022.

Do the maths. Rather than putting these people up in hotels and forcing them to spend their days in idleness, why not help them find their way to make a positive contribution to our economy and society?

These arrivals are but a small proportion of the people who come to live and work in Britain the vast majority of whom are licensed by direct invitation by His Majesty’s government partnering with the monopoly corporations and vast archipelago of smaller firms who desire, and need, a constant, if variable, flow of migrant workers.

Health and care are the main occupations drawing non-EU migration. There now is a higher demand for doctors, nurses and other groups of workers who were already eligible for visas under the old system.

Of course, some of these people are highly skilled and well-educated migrants, in some cases poached in a typically post-colonial parasitic relationship from countries whose economies need their skills more than does ours. But, as everyone can see, many migrant workers end up in low-paid jobs and some are super-exploited.

This is the pull factor driving immigration. Other push factors are equally a function of British capitalism in that decades of imperialist war in the Middle East continue to drive flows of migrants. And to these are added people driven from countries where climate change, for which their nations have made little contribution, means they are forced to move.

Rather than pandering to reactionary and racist mystification, our government should tell the plain truth about why people come to live and work here.

No clear understanding about the peculiarities of migration to and from these islands is possible without facing historical truths about the role of colonialism and slavery in our industrial revolution, our history of colonial and contemporary wars and the vital role of immigrants in rebuilding our war-shattered economy.

At the same time, the racism that finds fertile ground in myths about migration cannot be dissipated without a challenge, which in present circumstances must come from the left and the labour movement, against the dangerous growth of Reform UK.

Ad slot F - article bottom
More from this author
Features / 4 March 2020
4 March 2020
The Morning Star’s Alexander Norton spoke to the Connolly Youth Movement's ALEX HOMITS as he began his third term as General Secretary of the communist youth organisation, following the conclusion of its Ard Fheis (congress)
Interview / 8 November 2019
8 November 2019
First in a new series of Morning Star profiles, fast food worker Melissa Evans explains why it's time for a strike at the red and yellow flagship brand of capitalism itself: McDonald's
Features / 18 September 2019
18 September 2019
Speaking to Alexander Norton, WAHSAYAH WHITEBIRD talks about the opportunities and challenges in being the only explicitly Communist elected official in the English-speaking world
Opinion / 14 August 2019
14 August 2019
Far from being impulsive or incoherent, the anarchist’s extreme political beliefs are sadly consistent with extreme times, writes ALEXANDER NORTON
Similar stories
Features / 14 August 2024
14 August 2024
NICK WRIGHT dissects the contradictory views of Reform UK voters, finding significant opportunities for the left to challenge far-right narratives by addressing its voters’ legitimate economic concerns
Features / 18 January 2024
18 January 2024
In the face of mass migration, we don’t need to line up with the naive liberals and ‘no borders’ anarchists, nor with the xenophobic right — we need to identify the cause of this chaos, not attack or deny its symptoms, writes NICK WRIGHT
Features / 7 December 2023
7 December 2023
From misunderstanding the net gain made from foreign students to the need for workers to plug the gaps created by our ageing population, anti-immigration tropes need to be confronted, writes PAUL DONOVAN