Skip to main content
Big Brother is watching the poor and disabled

While claiming to target fraud, Labour’s snooping Bill strips benefit recipients of privacy rights and presumption of innocence, writes CLAUDIA WEBBE, warning that algorithms with up to 25 per cent error rates could wrongfully investigate and harass millions of vulnerable people

WAR ON CLAIMANTS: Liz Kendall outside the Department of Work and Pensions, March 2025

THE government’s Public Authorities (Fraud, Error and Recovery) Bill forces banks and other financial institutions to act as an extension of the state in snooping on the population of Britain. As is usually the case, the poor and vulnerable are the particular victims of this discriminatory proposed legislation, but the Bill fits into a wider landscape of “Big Brother,” surveillance-state government that should worry every British citizen, regardless of wealth or health.

DWP Secretary Liz Kendall, who has put forward the Bill as part of the Labour government’s wider war on benefit claimants and in particular the disabled and those with mental health issues, claims that the legislation is designed to combat fraud and organised crime. However, it will compel banks to spy on the account activity of anyone in receipt of any form of state benefits, and to report those it considers to have any form of even potentially suspicious transactions.

The mass nature of this surveillance means that it will inevitably be carried out by computers using algorithms and AI rather than by human beings, and as with all alogorithmically driven decisions there will be a significant error rate — with investigations and potentially penalties aimed at those who have done nothing wrong and had no idea they were in the government’s crosshairs until it is already well under way.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
The vote count on May 1 at Grimsby Town Hall, Lincolnshire, for the Greater Lincolnshire Mayor election
Features / 6 May 2025
6 May 2025

With Reform UK surging and Labour determined not to offer anything different from the status quo, a clear opportunity opens for the left, argues CLAUDIA WEBBE

Children sit and play on the remains of a tank, at the river
Features / 21 April 2025
21 April 2025

Keir Starmer’s £120 million to Sudan cannot cover the government’s complicity in the RSF genocide or atone for the long shadow of British colonialism and imperialism, writes CLAUDIA WEBBE

NO SAFE ZONES: Children walk by the destroyed house of journ
Features / 8 April 2025
8 April 2025
As Israel’s crimes escalate, Keir Starmer’s government must not subvert, block or ignore the investigation and prosecution of British citizens involved in acts of genocide, writes CLAUDIA WEBBE
DEFIANT: Mexican
President Claudia
Sheinbaum
Features / 10 March 2025
10 March 2025
With trade wars backfiring, allies resisting military demands, and approval ratings plummeting, Trump’s dangerous pursuit of colonial ambitions threatens to end the ‘American century’ with catastrophic conflict, warns CLAUDIA WEBBE
Similar stories
Britain / 2 April 2025
2 April 2025
A Universal Credit sign on a door of a job centre plus in ea
Britain / 22 January 2025
22 January 2025
Campaigners warn DWP proposals could be counterproductive and create a two-tier justice system