Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Labour’s customs union with the EU is a work in progress

Chuka Umunna’s and other Labour remainers’ hope that the Labour Party will support staying in the single market and the customs union were decisively dashed by Jeremy Corbyn in his much trailed speech in Coventry this week.

That Labour will honour the result of the EU referendum and leave the single market and the customs union and with it end the freedom of movement is not that new. What is new that will prove to be a giant leap forward for the Labour Party is Corbyn making it clear that remaining in either the single market or the customs union is incompatible with Labour’s radical plans for economic and industrial generation, regional development, state aid and state ownership of public utilities — a crucial understanding of the nature of the EU and its institutions that the majority of Labour members are yet to understand.  

Significant too was his recognition that the huge EU membership fees will after Brexit be spent on our public services.

Corbyn turned the TUC’s argument for staying in the single market and the customs union as the only way to secure jobs and rights on its head and stated the obvious: jobs and rights can only be secure when we are in charge, by our own actions outside the single market and the customs union and he outlined the measures Labour will take to that end.

The idea of a customs union between the Britain and the EU is clearly a work in progress with its contradictory aims and uncertain outcomes.

Contradictory aims because on the one hand it binds us to EU trade deals while negotiating our own and protecting our national interest when the EU has the German, French and 25 other national interests to consider, as well as its own overriding interest in remaining relevant and in charge.

There are great uncertainties in such a strategy including the possibility of maintaining the high tariffs on food products that penalise developing countries and the possibility of imposing the Canadian equivalent of TTIP, Ceta, on Britain.

If the purpose of considering a customs union is to ensure no return to a hard border in the island of Ireland, then it is unnecessary.

A study commissioned by the EU in November 2017 “identified international standards, best practices and technologies that can be used to avoid a hard border.”

In any case, a customs union as such does not prevent a hard border as the EU/Turkey customs union proves.

If Britain is to keep the very same trading relationship with the EU after Brexit as now, it begs the question: aren’t these the very arrangements that did so much damage to our industry and manufacturing?

Does the fact that a mini car will have its component parts criss-crossing the channel several times before it is finally assembled in Wales serve the interest of workers and the environment, or is it just a way for corporations to make more profit?

Others in the Labour Party, less clear on the issues, must be very wary of appearing to undermine and weaken the hand of those engaged in negotiating with a foreign body on behalf of the country and its people; parties that do that will be punished at the polls.

Fawzi Ibrahim is a national officer of Trade Unionists Against the EU.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
IN THE BELLY OF THE BEAST:
Thousands of protesters march
aga
Opinion / 24 February 2025
24 February 2025
Lenin’s theory of the weakest link shifted the centre of gravity of the proletarian revolution towards peoples’ struggles in the developing world, contrary to the expectation of Marx and Engels. The effect was to hinder the cause of socialism by decades. Time bring it back to its natural home, argues FAWZI IBRAHIM
Opinion / 14 November 2024
14 November 2024
There is a lot to be said for Labour’s first Budget in 14 years, says FAWZI IBRAHIM, arguing that rebuilding the country’s infrastructure and its industrial base through wealth creation is the antidote to a capitalism in absolute decline
Thousands march to Trafalgar Square in central London, to ce
Opinion / 17 June 2024
17 June 2024
The reliance on political parties to bring about socialist change in Britain has proved a total failure says FAWZI IBRAHIM. Time for the true representatives of the working class, the trade unions, to take a direct role in asserting their will on the government of the day
TUC CONGRESS 2023 / 11 September 2023
11 September 2023
We have been fighting things getting worse — what is needed is to fight to get things better, and that requires a radical change in mindset, writes national officer of Rebuild Britain FAWZI IBRAHIM
Similar stories
The Union flag, Saltire and EU flag fly outside the Scottish
Britain / 31 January 2025
31 January 2025

Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar during First Minister's
Britain / 18 October 2024
18 October 2024
European Union flags wave in the wind as pedestrians walk by
Features / 25 July 2024
25 July 2024
As Starmer hints at closer ties, MARTIN HALL warns of the dangers of creeping alignment and calls for a renewed socialist case for independence from Brussels, especially over the EU’s constraints on economic planning