Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
The NAO report into underpayment of ESA must not obscure the real scandal
Disabled People Against Cuts protest outside Parliament against government cuts to Personal Independent Payments in March 2017

THE figures involved and the sheer incompetence revealed by the National Audit Office’s report into the underpayment of employment and support allowance (ESA) obscure the real effect of the scandal.

Tens of thousands of disabled people, already forced to rely on meagre government benefits, have been forced into further hardship by the callous and unthinking officials of the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

It boggles the mind that the problem has rumbled on for so many years, starting in 2010. The auditors put this politely, writing that the DWP “process for converting people’s benefits to ESA … did not reflect its own legislation.”

In plain language, they broke the law. This was made clear to DWP chiefs by tribunal decisions in 2014 and 2015. What did they do? What action did they take to make amends to the people whose lives had been worsened by their incompetence?

The DWP “did not recognise” that the rulings should prompt action “to identify people whose legal entitlements might be affected.” A 2015 judgement “prompted discussion but no clear action.”

Whatever tosh the Tories and all those on the right, including still far too many in the Labour Party, might spew about benefits, people do not go to the DWP for some bonus dosh so they can live a lavish life.

Its benefits are our society’s safety net, though at this point worn and ragged and full of gaping holes.

So while any common-sense person might reasonably try, when confronted with evidence that their actions had been depriving people for years, to make some kind of amends for their mistake, it appears that this never occurred to DWP chiefs.

Not in 2013 when the mistake was spotted in individual cases, not in 2014 when it was clear the problem was systemic, not after the 2014 and 2015 tribunal rulings.

Not even in early 2017, when ministers were briefed that they should still hold off while they checked with the lawyers. Unsurprisingly, the lawyers came back in the summer and made clear they were on the hook.

But, thanks to a 1998 law, only on the hook for repayments back to the 2014 tribunal ruling, meaning that, while £340 million is to be paid out, another nearly £150m of underpayments from beforehand will simply be swept under the rug.

It may seem tedious to till over this ground when the headline figures are shocking enough, forming “a measure of the government’s utter incompetence” in the words of Labour’s Margaret Greenwood.

But it is instructive as to the approach taken by the government — this one, the Conservative-Liberal Democratic coalition and, yes, the Blair-Brown New Labour administration, along with their predecessors for years.

The sheer reluctance to act, to make things right, to help those already clearly in need shows the entrenched view that those forced to go hat in hand to the DWP are scroungers, that they are unworthy of anything but contempt.

It is the disgusting anti-social ideology of the capitalist class, where only profit and the means with which to make it are valued in any way.

We have seen this poison driven deeper into the heart of our vital and treasured institutions for decades — the NHS, schools and universities, the railways, the probation service, you name it.

It is not a matter of swapping a bunch of incompetents for people who know what they are doing, but a more fundamental reconstruction of the bodies on which our society relies.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Keir Starmer
Editorial / 23 May 2025
23 May 2025
Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves speaks with the media at the Rolls-Royce factory in Derby, following the announcement from the Office for National Statistics that the UK economy grew by 0.7% between January and March, May 15, 2025
Editorial: / 15 May 2025
15 May 2025
Similar stories
CHANGE SLOW TO COME: Scotland Justice Secretary Angela Constance (SNP) meets prison officers during a visit the new HMP and YOI Stirling
Probation Service / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

IAN LAWRENCE welcomes the government sentencing review but warns past experience shows such words rarely translate into meaningful action

HARMFUL RHETORIC: Keir Starmer and Liz Kendall
Features / 3 February 2025
3 February 2025
Far from addressing the causes of ill-health and disability, Starmer, Reeves and Kendall are committed to unleashing more misery for disabled people, argues Dr DYLAN MURPHY
AN IMPERATIVE CALL: Haldane Society of Socialist Lawyers pro
Features / 11 January 2025
11 January 2025
PROFESSOR ANSELM ELDERGILL suggests ways in which the government can boost legal aid and support
Features / 19 August 2024
19 August 2024
Stripped of their industrial muscle and left at the mercy of ministers and management, prison officers have been pushed way beyond breaking point, warns STEVE GILLAN