Skip to main content
Work with the NEU
The NAO report into underpayment of ESA must not obscure the real scandal
Disabled People Against Cuts protest outside Parliament against government cuts to Personal Independent Payments in March 2017

THE figures involved and the sheer incompetence revealed by the National Audit Office’s report into the underpayment of employment and support allowance (ESA) obscure the real effect of the scandal.

Tens of thousands of disabled people, already forced to rely on meagre government benefits, have been forced into further hardship by the callous and unthinking officials of the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

It boggles the mind that the problem has rumbled on for so many years, starting in 2010. The auditors put this politely, writing that the DWP “process for converting people’s benefits to ESA … did not reflect its own legislation.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Anthony Wedgwood Benn with his wife after the Election Court sitting at the Law Courts, which decided that Benn has succeeded to the title of Lord Stansgate and is therefore disqualified from the House of Commons
Tony Benn / 9 August 2026
9 August 2026

Tony Benn’s constituents chose him by an overwhelming majority — but because he had inherited a peerage, parliamentary rules declared their choice invalid, writes MAT COWARD

STARMER’S CUTS MAN: Alan Milburn at a presentation of his interim Report into Young People and Work, at West Library Youth Employment Hub, north London, May 28 2026
Diane Abbott / 6 August 2026
6 August 2026

As a proportion of GDP the total welfare bill is lower than it was 15 years ago. The claim that it is spiralling out of control is mythmaking, argues DIANE ABBOTT

UNION RIGHTS ARE HUMAN RIGHTS: St Mungo's workers outside the homeless charity's head quarters in Tower Hill, London, as they start a month long strike over pay, May 2023
Workers' Rights / 21 March 2026
21 March 2026

The unions are unhappy with the Employment Rights Act 2025 and with good reason. KEITH EWING and Lord JOHN HENDY KC take a close look at why the Bill promised more than it delivered

MUSICAL CHAIR AT No 10: Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer addresses the reshuffled Cabinet on September 9 2025
Eyes Left / 10 September 2025
10 September 2025

A ‘new phase’ for Starmerism is fairly similar to the old phase – only worse. ANDREW MURRAY takes a look