Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
SNP's anti-Brexit stance ‘sets a template’ to block independence, former deputy leader says
First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon addresses anti-Brexit campaigners in Parliament Square as they take part in the People's Vote March in London yesterday

The SNP’s opposition to Brexit has “set a template for the unionists” to block independence, a former deputy leader of the party said today.

Jim Sillars said his party’s support for a second referendum on European Union membership would cause “a lot of complications and a lot of opportunity for Ruth Davidson to go and tell the Tory Prime Minister to make it as difficult as possible” for Scotland to separate from the UK.

Speaking at a Morning Star conference in Glasgow on Scotland’s future constitutional settlement, the former MP said: “The present conduct of the SNP and their anti-Brexit campaign has set a template for the unionists to stop us fulfilling a Yes vote.

“The moment you say that the question on the ballot paper that people voted on is not legitimate, then the unionists pocket that away.”

Mr Sillars also criticised Scottish Constitutional Relations Secretary Mike Russell for seemingly implying that Tory MPs who voted for Theresa May’s Brexit deal were traitors.

The SNP cabinet minister tweeted the 11 MPs’ names along with the hashtag #RagmanRoll, a reference to Scottish aristocrats who pledged allegiance to the English crown in the 13th century.

“In the highest reaches of the Scottish government there are those who imply their opponents on Brexit are traitors,” Mr Sillars said.

“And that shows a lamentable failure to exercise the personal constraints [sic] that should be practised by all leaders in a democracy.

“We have the right to think differently; it’s democracy’s foundation. And in the situation we’re in today, where the whole climate can be changed to a hateful climate, to use language like the Ragman Roll against those who don’t agree with them, actually, is an extremely dangerous thing.”

Mr Sillars argued that “even if there was an independence referendum and we won it on the Yes side,” it would not “be easy to get it” due to “what the SNP has done in its anti-Brexit campaign.”

He added: “So I don’t think that I can talk about the powers necessary in an independent Scotland, because I think that’s off the agenda for some time.”

Speaking at the same event, Labour councillor and parliamentary candidate Matt Kerr deplored the “tragic” failure of the Scottish parliament to assert itself as a force for innovative policy-making, adding: “There’s good people in there, but they’re caught up in a mass of managerialism.”

Mr Sillars went on to call for Scotland to take control of its offshore industry, exploiting undersea oil and gas reserves to the north of the country and in the Firth of Clyde and to not let the profits be sucked up by international conglomerates.

Labour peer Pauline Bryan stressed her party’s prioritisation of the green economy, which shadow chancellor John McDonnell said could create 50,000 new jobs north of the border under a Labour government.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
Similar stories
Alex Salmond speaks at the SNP conference in Glasgow, Octobe
Features / 17 October 2024
17 October 2024
JOHN FOSTER examines how the late SNP leader shifted the party leftwards and upwards, bringing Scottish independence to the forefront while fundamentally failing to address deeper issues of class and corporate capture
Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes speaks to the media in fro
Britain / 22 July 2024
22 July 2024
Former SNP MP Mhairi Black made the remarks about Kate Forbes as she promotes her new venture
Deputy First Minister Kate Forbes and First Minister John Sw
Britain / 11 July 2024
11 July 2024
Scottish First Minister and SNP leader John Swinney giving a
Britain / 10 July 2024
10 July 2024