Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Remember the Revolution as the best in MLS in 2021
JAMES NALTON provides an insight into Major League Soccer as the season approaches its end
New England Revolution goalkeeper Matt Turner dives misses a penalty during the shoot out after the MLS playoff match against New York City FC, Tuesday, November 30, 2021

The 2021 Major League Soccer (MLS) season is approaching its end. The two Conference Finals took place last weekend and the winners, Portland Timbers and New York City, will contest Saturday’s MLS Cup Final.

As is the case with a number of league seasons in the Americas, including Brazil, Argentina and Canada, the season is currently played across a calendar year rather than spanning two as most European leagues do.

The league champions were crowned in October with New England Revolution lifting the trophy — the Supporters’ Shield — after the final game of the regular season early last month.

It was the first time the Revolution had topped the league at the end of the season, and they did so in style, breaking the league’s points record and boasting its best player, Carles Gil (once of Aston Villa).

The problem for New England and their coach Bruce Arena is that in MLS, as is the case across US sport, the champions tag for a particular season isn’t attached to the team that tops the league, but to the team that wins the post-season playoffs — in this case, the MLS Cup.

The other issue for New England is that they have already been knocked out of those playoffs, losing to New York City on penalties in last week’s Conference semifinals.

This defeat has somewhat tarnished their achievements during the regular season, but it shouldn’t.

There’s no doubt a league table decides the best team and the best players in a particular season. It is football’s test match — the true test of management, squad depth, coaching, togetherness, tactics, training, consistency and everything else.

This remains the case even in MLS where there are issues with who plays who across 27 teams (soon to be 28) and two conferences in a 34-game campaign.

But despite New England’s record-breaking feats during the regular season, they will not be widely considered 2021 MLS champions, as should be the case, with this accolade instead going to the MLS Cup winners.

This isn’t to say the playoffs don’t have their place. On the contrary. It shows how interesting, exciting and ultimately worthwhile post-season playoffs can be.

Changes that would Europeanise North American football are regularly suggested by those who follow the sport on both sides of the pond.

This is already happening in some areas, not least in the fact that most expansion teams in recent years have been called FC, United, or City, as opposed to the more flamboyant or quirky names previously seen in the region.

While the game in North America would benefit from some changes — changes that would make it more attractive globally and, more importantly, provide a platform for football in the US and Canada below or aside from MLS — the sport in the region should look to conserve its unique character.

The playoffs are part of that. A party at the end of the season. A mini-cup competition qualified for on merit, but one in which every team involved believes they have a chance of progressing in one-off games.

Getting the balance right between a meaningful post-season cup competition and acknowledging the feats achieved by the best team during the regular season has proven difficult.

There was a sense after New England’s playoff defeat that their season ended in failure.

Topping the Eastern Conference gave them a bye to the semi-finals, but also meant they were inactive for almost a month and didn't really help their cause.

The leaders of the Western Conference at the end of the regular season, Colorado Rapids, were also knocked out at the first time of asking in their Conference semifinal against Portland Timbers.

Arena was named Coach of the Year in this year’s official MLS awards and Rapids coach Fraser runner-up, but both saw their teams unceremoniously dumped out of the playoffs.

After New England’s defeat to NYC, questions were asked whether Arena would stay on into next year.

Maybe they would have been asked even if he’d won the MLS Cup but, in this context, there was an atmosphere around the discourse that gave the impression he’d ultimately failed due to their playoff exit.

Asking to attach more prestige to the Supporters' Shield than is attached to the MLS Cup is difficult as it is a mindset embedded in North American sport, but not considering a league champion a failure if they exit the playoffs would be a start.

As for the playoffs themselves, as you take in the drama over the three-week period you can understand their appeal, in North American sport or otherwise.

They are part of the character of football in the region that should be preserved.

That character remains in teams such as New England Revolution. An original MLS team with a name you’re unlikely to get in any other part of the world, and the best team in MLS in 2021.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani takes selfies with supporters after speaking at his primary election party, June 25, 2025, in New York
Men’s football / 27 June 2025
27 June 2025

JAMES NALTON writes how at the heart of the big apple, the beautiful game exists as something more community-oriented, which could benefit hugely under mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani

President Donald Trump meets with members of the Juventus soccer club in the Oval Office of the White House, Wednesday, June 18, 2025, in Washington.
Men’s football / 20 June 2025
20 June 2025

JAMES NALTON discusses how Fifa claims to be apolitical, but as Infantino and Juventus players stood behind Trump discussing war, gender, and global politics, the line between sport and statecraft vanished

Law enforcement personnel walk outside Hard Rock Stadium during preparations for Saturday's opening match in the Club World Cup soccer tournament, June 11, 2025, in Miami Gardens, Fla.
Men's Football / 13 June 2025
13 June 2025

The competition sounds good on paper, and has potential to be great, but Fifa has gone out of its way to mess it up, JAMES NALTON explains

Liverpool fans set off flares outside the stadium ahead of the Premier League match at Anfield, Liverpool, April 27, 2025
Men’s football / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

As Liverpool lifted the title and Everton said goodbye to Goodison, Merseyside’s unity shone through in the face of tragedy, writes JAMES NALTON

Similar stories
Los Angeles Galaxy's Marco Reus (left) celebrates with teamm
Men’s football / 6 December 2024
6 December 2024
JAMES NALTON previews the much-anticipated East Coast versus West Coast battle this weekend, the result of supporters holding their team to account
Men’s football / 22 November 2024
22 November 2024
JAMES NALTON writes how both NY teams have avoided each other in the much anticipated post-season competition that determines who will be champions - until now
Inter Miami's Lionel Messi (left) and Luis Suarez celebrate
Men's Football / 4 October 2024
4 October 2024
JAMES NALTON celebrates a unique and valued prize that is the Supporters Shield
Inter Miami forward Lionel Messi (second right) celebrates w
Men’s football / 1 October 2024
1 October 2024