Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Debt, a core tool of capitalism
Far from being opposed to it, capitalism depends on debt as a way of enforcing loyalty to the profit system from those that have the least to gain from it, explains JOHN GREEN
The debt phenomenon is not just found in the housing market and the student loan business, but everywhere you look. Capitalists depend on selling ever more products; if they can’t sell, they make no profit. That is why we are urged to buy ever more consumer items by slick advertising and seductive publicity.

BEING in debt and being unable to pay it off is one of the recurring nightmares for so many people and it has been the basis for many tragic lives in novels — most famously in Charles Dickens’s David Copperfield.

In David Copperfield, the clerk Wilkins Micawber was incarcerated in a debtors’ prison after failing to meet his creditors’ demands. His long-suffering wife Emma stood by him, despite his financial exigencies that forced her to pawn all her family’s possessions.

Micawber’s name has become synonymous with someone who lives in hopeful expectation but is always financially on the edge. This has formed the basis for the Micawber Principle: “Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure nineteen and six, result happiness. Annual income twenty pounds, annual expenditure twenty pounds nought and six, result misery.”

Dickens’s novel was set in the Victorian era, but today we appear to be returning to that era with a vengeance, even if we no longer have specific debtors’ prisons anymore.

More and more individuals and families are falling into debt, being evicted from their homes and placed under enormous stress, leading to mental health problems. And this is happening despite a continued rise in living standards.

The late anarchist and anthropologist David Graeber in his book, Debt, The First 5,000 Years, argued that debt is at the root of the capitalist system.

A major argument of his book is that the informal indebtedness of “human economies” is only replaced by mathematically precise, firmly enforced debts through the introduction of violence, usually state-sponsored violence, by military forces or the police.

He also argues, contrary to standard accounts of the history of money, that debt is probably the oldest means of trade, with cash and barter transactions being later developments — although this assertion has been challenged by many economists and historians.

Graeber stated that “markets are founded and usually maintained by systematic state violence,” though he goes on to show how “in the absence of such violence, they ... can even come to be seen as the very basis of freedom and autonomy.”

While it might smack of conspiracy theory, it is undoubtedly true that as far as the capitalists are concerned, having someone in debt to them is a sure way of keeping the latter subservient and beholden, so the more people who are in debt, the more malleable and controllable they become.

If you are worried about losing your home, your car and other belongings, the last thing on your mind will be joining demonstrations or campaigns to end this vicious cycle.

This was clearly the logic behind Thatcher’s policy of turning everyone into a property owner. If you remember, she forced councils to sell off all their housing stocks at knockdown prices to those who wanted to buy their own homes. Her reasoning was that property owners are more likely to vote Conservative.

In addition, most home-buyers wouldn’t actually own the houses and flats they lived in outright, as most would be obliged to take out mortgages in order to pretend that they did. In this way, they would be firmly locked into the capitalist debt system.

Once you are locked into having to pay off a mortgage each month — a variable amount that can rise or fall, but always seems to rise — you are trapped. If you fail to pay the regular monthly interest instalments, you can be kicked out onto the street, so the pressure to keep paying is a strong one, and workers will be less likely to take strike action as they would fall behind with their repayments.

To previous generations, such indebtedness affected working adults and families, but not the young. Today’s students also find themselves locked into debt right from the beginning, before they even begin to earn a living. After taking out loans — which everyone not from a wealthy family is forced to do — they will begin their working lives already with a huge debt hanging around their necks.

Apart from the economic burden itself, debt can be instrumentalised to suppress student dissent and protest. You won’t be too willing to boycott lectures and take time off to demonstrate on the streets if it is going to cost you money (increased debt), possible expulsion from college, or being blacklisted in the jobs market.

Some bright spark will undoubtedly say: “Well Marx was always in debt but that didn’t stop him from fomenting revolution!” While that is true in Marx’s case, he had someone, namely his friend Engels, who was wealthy enough to bail him out. Without Engels, Marx himself may have ended up in a debtors’ prison and we would have had no Capital! Most students don’t have that luxury.

The debt phenomenon is not just found in the housing market and the student loan business, but everywhere you look. Capitalists depend on selling ever more products; if they can’t sell, they make no profit. That is why we are urged to buy ever more consumer items by slick advertising and seductive publicity.

The system depends on selling, even if the items it is selling are not really wanted or needed. It does this by spending huge sums on advertising. Never mind if you don’t have the money now, just buy, buy, buy on the never-never (hire purchase). We are told we can have what we want and pay for it later, encouraging more indebtedness.

The terrible implications of indebtedness can also be seen on an international level. Many of the less developed countries have found themselves amassing huge debts by taking out loans from the IMF or World Bank and by purchasing expensive weaponry.

They then find themselves tied into a subservient, client relationship with the big lenders who can and do dictate these countries’ political and economic policies.

The recent establishment of the Brics group of nations, and the flexing of muscles by a number of these indebted countries which found themselves in a neocolonial trap, is an encouraging sign that this use of debt to maintain imperialist global domination is perhaps coming to an end.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
fall
Book Review / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

JOHN GREEN wades through a pessimistic prophesy that does not consider the need for radical change in political and social structures

CONTESTED HISTORY: The Neue Wache (“the New Watchhouse”) was rebuilt by the GDR in 1957 and reopened in 1960 as a Memorial to the Victims of Fascism and Militarism — then, in 1993, it was rededicated to the ‘victims of war and tyranny’
Features / 26 May 2025
26 May 2025

JOHN GREEN observes how Berlin’s transformation from socialist aspiration to imperial nostalgia mirrors Germany’s dangerous trajectory under Chancellor Merz — a BlackRock millionaire and anti-communist preparing for a new war with Russia

221
Film of the week / 1 May 2025
1 May 2025

JOHN GREEN recommends a German comedy that celebrates the old GDR values of solidarity, community and a society not dominated by consumerism

Mural depicting the symbol of the revolution - a soldier with a carnation in the barrel of his gun; People celebrating on top of a tank in Lisbon during the Carnation Revolution of April 25 1974 / Pics: IsmailKupeli/CC; Public domain
Books / 24 April 2025
24 April 2025

JOHN GREEN welcomes an insider account of the achievements and failures of the transition to democracy in Portugal

Similar stories
Actors rehearsing for a performance of Another Christmas Car
Features / 28 December 2024
28 December 2024
Charles Dickens was facing a return to the destitution that had blighted his childhood, and it was this which drove him to write the remarkable best-seller which changed the politics of Christmas forever, writes MAT COWARD
Prime Minister Keir Starmer speaking on day two of the Cop29
Features / 28 December 2024
28 December 2024
The cynical lack of clarity over Cop29’s financial arrangements suggests that the bill will be footed by poor countries, writes TOM HARDY
HOUSING CRISIS: Campaigners protesting the destruction of co
Features / 9 November 2024
9 November 2024
MARTIN WICKS argues that the government’s reduced discounts for council house purchases don’t go far enough, and we need to be calling for the complete abolition of this regressive Thatcherite policy