Skip to main content
Regional secretary with the National Education Union
World Rugby rebukes 
Schmidt’s safety claim

Governing body says officials acted within laws and player welfare remains top priority

Australia head coach Joe Schmidt during the Captain's Run at the Melbourne Cricket Ground in Melbourne, Australia, July 22, 2025

WORLD RUGBY rejects Joe Schmidt’s claim that the decision not to punish Jac Morgan’s clearout in Australia’s defeat by the British and Irish Lions on Saturday contravenes the game’s player safety principles.

Hugo Keenan touched down with 51 seconds left at the Melbourne Cricket Ground, but the match-winning try was only given after the TMO had reviewed Morgan’s contact with Carlo Tizzano in the preceding ruck, which was ultimately deemed legal by referee Andrea Piardi.

Furious Schmidt, who had seen his Wallabies edged 29-26 to concede the series with one Test to play, insisted it was the wrong call, adding that “it doesn’t really live up to the big player safety push that they [World Rugby] are talking about”.

Rugby Australia chief executive Phil Waugh backed Schmidt’s view that it was a dangerous clearout and the try should have been disallowed.

World Rugby has been conducting a review into the incident in conjunction with Australia, the Lions and the match officials, which will be completed in time for Saturday’s final Test between the rivals in Sydney.

Chief executive Alan Gilpin, speaking at an event revealing ticketing details for the 2027 World Cup, has hit back at Schmidt.

“It’s disappointing when the reaction is one of ‘this means player welfare isn’t taken seriously’ because we have worked really hard on that narrative,” said Gilpjn, who revealed Schmidt will not face disciplinary action for his comments.

“Everyone knows we are putting player welfare, in its broadest sense, at the top of the agenda.

“You can see that from what we are doing with the instrumented mouthguards, all the research, the science, the investigations.

“The way the laws of the game have evolved in the last few years is all about ‘how do we have this great physical contest, but make it as safe as possible?’. That part is challenging, in terms of the player welfare statements.”

Gilpin insists Piardi and his assistants Ben O’Keeffe and Nika Amashukeli are being supported amid the backlash against the officials in some quarters.

And the World Rugby boss invoked Rassie Erasmus’s public criticism of Nic Berry during the Lions’ tour to South Africa in 2021 and the experiences of retired referee Wayne Barnes, who has spoken of the abuse his family received, to highlight the importance of protecting officials.

“It’s just making them realise they’re supported and that we are checking in on them. They’re a great unit. They’ve been together on this tour as a team,” Gilpin said.

“You’ll recall that in the last Lions series in South Africa, when the match official in the first Test was very heavily criticised … the mental health challenges …

“Wayne Barnes has talked about it. We’ve got match officials who, when they’re criticised publicly, see their families targeted outside the school gates.

“That’s not good, that’s not fair and that’s not right, so we’ve got to support these guys.”

Lions fly-half Finn Russell had accused Tizzano of making the most of the challenge, stating that he “obviously holds his head and tried to get a penalty from it.”

But having being relayed Gilpin’s comments today, Schmidt revealed the extent of the damage sustained by the Wallabies flanker.

“Talking about the instrumental mouthguards, with Carlo when he was hit, I feel sorry for him because he’s copping a lot of flak, but that impact was almost double what they determine as a high magnitude impact,” Schmidt told Stan Sports.

“So that’s the degree of force that he had to wear. And that in itself is enough to force someone to recoil as he did. So those are some of the things that we get actual readings on.

“He’s had a pretty sore neck for the last 24-48 hours. But he’s back, he’s resilient and he’s back looking forward to the weekend.”

Australia 2027 has released details of its ticketing plan for the next World Cup, with fans able to register to access the presale now.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Chelsea's Joao Felix after the UEFA Europa Conference League match at Stamford Bridge, London, November 7, 2024
Men’s football / 29 July 2025
29 July 2025
India head coach Gautam Gambhir during a nets session at Emirates Old Trafford, Manchester, July 21, 2025
Men’s cricket / 29 July 2025
29 July 2025
McLaren driver Oscar Piastri of Australia celebrates on the podium after winning the Formula One Grand Prix at the Spa-Francorchamps racetrack in Spa, Belgium, Sunday, July 27, 2025
Formula One / 27 July 2025
27 July 2025

Grand Prix delayed by one hour and 20 minutes due to heavy rain in the Ardennes

Similar stories
Harlequins' Tom Lawday (centre) is tackled by Glasgow Warriors' Gregor Brown during the Investec Champions Cup match at the Twickenham Stoop Stadium, London, January 18, 2025
Men's Rugby Union / 20 July 2025
20 July 2025
Australia's Hunter Paisami during the Autumn International match at the Principality Stadium, Cardiff, November 20, 2021
Men's Rugby Union / 25 June 2025
25 June 2025
Jay McLean and Alton Walley perform a Welcome to Country ceremony for the British and Irish Lions players in Kings Park in Perth, Australia, Monday, June 23, 2025
Men’s Rugby Union / 23 June 2025
23 June 2025

Wallabies warned over potential breach of contract if they fail to release Test players

Australia head coach Joe Schmidt before the Autumn internati
Men's rugby union / 29 November 2024
29 November 2024