Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Tory cap on unaccompanied child refugees allowed into Britain challenged in the High Court
Lord Dubs and Joely Richardson attend a Citizens UK event in October 2016 outside the Home Office in London, to welcome the arrival of the first child refugees as the Calais 'jungle' demolition begins

CAMPAIGNERS’ challenge to the Tory cap on the number of unaccompanied child refugees allowed into Britain opened at the Court of Appeal today.

Help Refugees is fighting the Home Office decision to limit the number of children allowed to seek asylum in Britain under the Dubs amendment, named after Labour peer Alf Dubs, who came to Britain with the Kindertransport in 1939.

In November, the High Court threw out the charity’s attempt to force the Home Office to abandon the cap and reopen its “defective” consultation.

But Help Refugees argue that the current cap of just 480 children does not “accurately reflect the capacity of local authorities” to provide children with places as a result of a “confusing” consultation process.

The group’s QC Nathalie Lieven said children in France who were refused a place in Britain were not even given “short written reasons” as to why they were not accepted.

She said children already found it difficult to challenge a refusal due to “formidable barriers” such as their age, lack of English or French and, in particular, trauma caused by fleeing their home country without their family.

Ms Lieven said: “The obstacles for lone, unrepresented children based overseas seeking judicial review of unlawful decisions become almost insurmountable if they have neither written decisions nor written reasons.”

She quoted from internal Home Office emails, telling the court that they showed “the reason for not giving reasons was that the lawyers had advised that they should not be given because it would open them up to legal challenge.”

Ms Lieven added that the “confusing” consultation process “caused, or at least encouraged” a misunderstanding among Scottish authorities which led to just six places being offered across the whole of Scotland.

The Home Office argues that the High Court’s decision was correct.

Help Refugees CEO Josie Naughton said before the hearing: “The child refugee crisis has not gone away: there are, for example, nearly 4,000 unaccompanied refugee children in Greece right now, two-thirds of whom are living in destitution, exposed to trafficking and other serious abuse.

“The slow pace of relocations has been shocking. There are children disappearing from camps and settlements in mainland Europe while local authority places offered for Dubs children remain unused.”

The hearing continues.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Britain / 17 June 2021
17 June 2021
All eight claimants say Labour acted unfairly by failing to close investigations or revoke their suspension or expulsion
Similar stories
Pro-government supporters hold up signs with the image of Maikelys Espinoza, a 2-year-old in US custody whose parents were deported separately, at a rally in Caracas, Venezuela, Thursday, May 1, 2025
Latin America / 10 May 2025
10 May 2025

Calls have been made for the return to Venezuela of a two-year-old girl currently being held in the US, after being separated from her family by immigration officials, reports SUSAN GREY

Lord Alf Dubs on stage addressing the crowd during a rally in Parliament Square, London, after taking part in the Refugees Welcome March, September 2016
Features / 6 May 2025
6 May 2025

A recent Immigration Summit heard from Lord Alf Dubs, who fled the Nazis to Britain as a child. JAYDEE SEAFORTH reports on his message that we need to increase public empathy with desperate people seeking asylum