Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Everton's root and branch reform needs to start at the top
JAMES NALTON argues that whatever ‘sacking the board’ involves, it is surely the only option left for the Toffees
Everton's James Tarkowski and team-mates react after they concede a fourth goal during the Premier League match at Goodison Park, Liverpool

CHANTS of “sack the board” rang out around Goodison Park during Everton’s second-half collapse against Brighton & Hove Albion last week.

Whatever sacking the board involves, it is surely the only option left for Everton now. 

A restructuring of the board may not be enough. New ownership may be needed to take the club forward in a game, and a league, that has advanced beyond the current leadership’s capabilities.

At Everton’s annual general meeting in January 2021, chairman Bill Kenwright boasted: “I believe that the Everton board is revered throughout football — I know all the boards in football — and I know that our board is what other football clubs aspire to.

“In fact, one very famous football club said to me two or three days ago, ‘whenever we have a problem, we say what would the Everton board do? Because they always get it right.’

“Maybe you don’t know what a chairman does,” Kenwright added. “It’s my job to uphold everything that is good and I believe is right for Everton.”

At this point it would appear to be the right thing for Everton, is new leadership in the boardroom and new ownership.

It is worth pointing at this stage out that Everton’s community arm, Everton in the Community, continues to do good work off the pitch. Maybe the sporting side of the football club can learn some things from them.

Managers have come and gone, and current boss Frank Lampard is now in a precarious position with the club dropping ever closer to the foot of the table.

Even directors of football have come and gone — the very job supposed to provide stability at a club. But for various reasons, often beyond their control, those in this post have been unable to carry out this role, often due to ownership interference.

During the past year, there has been a root and branch review of football operations at Everton.

A new director of football, Kevin Thelwell, was hired to revamp that structure (in a solely sporting sense) which he has attempted to do with numerous appointments in the past year in all areas of the football operation.

One appointment he didn’t make was Lampard. This itself is an immediate red flag as the hiring of a director of football should come before the hiring of a manager. It sums up Everton in their current state that it didn’t.

The club were pressed into a managerial appointment earlier due to poor results under Rafa Benitez midway through the 2021/22 season, but those poor results are being reflected in the 2022/23 campaign.

Lampard and Benitez evidently weren’t, or aren’t, good enough to turn things around. They weren’t the right managers for the job, but neither are they the main problem.

Everton fans indicated the main problem when they turned their ire towards the board during Tuesday’s embarrassing 4-1 defeat.

Their opponents that night, Brighton, are the complete opposite of Everton at this moment in time. 

They are a well-run club with good recruitment. They have an idea of how they want to play and the players, and indeed the coaches and managers, who can implement it.

It seemed impossible for them to improve on what Graham Potter had brought to the club before he left for Chelsea, but they might be even better to watch under Potter’s replacement, Roberto De Zerbi.

Brighton know the profiles they need in all roles at the club, from playing staff to coaching staff and beyond, and let each do the job they were hired for.

Some Everton fans applauded Brighton off the pitch at the end of Tuesday’s game, enviously, no doubt, but also in appreciation of what a well-run club looks like.

For the home team, there were boos at the end of the game, almost obligatory now. 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Argentina's Lionel Messi celebrates scoring his side's third goal against Venezuela during a World Cup 2026 qualifying soccer match at the Monumental stadium in Buenos Aires, Argentina, Thursday, Sept. 4, 2025
Men’s football / 5 September 2025
5 September 2025

The captain’s emotional performance in Argentina’s win over Venezuela had all the markings of a farewell. But if history is any guide, the legend may not be done just yet, writes JAMES NALTON

Grimsby Town's goalkeeper Christy Pym (right) is congratulated by his teammates after they win the penalty shoot out during the Carabao Cup second round match at Hill Blundell Park, Grimsby, August 27, 2025
Men’s football / 29 August 2025
29 August 2025

As football grapples with overloaded calendars and commercial pressure, the Mariners’ triumph reminds us why the game’s soul lives far from the spotlight, writes JAMES NALTON

Everton's Iliman Ndiaye celebrates scoring their side's first goal of the game during the Premier League match at the Hill Dickinson Stadium, Liverpool. Picture date: Sunday August 24, 2025
Men's Football / 24 August 2025
24 August 2025
Bayern Munich's Harry Kane with The Bundesliga Meisterschale (championship shield) at the Allianz Arena, Munich, after his side won the Bundesliga title. Picture date: Saturday May 10, 2025
Men's Football / 22 August 2025
22 August 2025

JAMES NALTON takes a look at the German league’s move to grow its audience in Britain, and around the future of football on TV in general

Similar stories
Everton fans let off flares before the Premier League match at Goodison Park, Liverpool, May 18, 2025
Men’s football / 18 May 2025
18 May 2025
Everton fans in the stands ahead of the Premier League match at Goodison Park, Liverpool, April 19, 2025
Men’s football / 21 April 2025
21 April 2025

As the historic ground prepares for its emotional farewell, even visiting teams like Manchester City are paying tribute to one of English football’s most storied stadiums, writes JAMES NALTON

West Ham United's Max Kilman (centre) clears the ball away f
Men’s football / 16 March 2025
16 March 2025
A view of a corner flag before the FA Cup third round match
Men’s Football / 10 January 2025
10 January 2025
JAMES NALTON reflects on times spent at Everton’s home ground and the sadness that English football is losing a link to its past and tradition