Skip to main content
The rise of Reform spooks Tories and challenges the left
Reform Party leader Richard Tice speaking at a press conference at the Conrad Hilton, London, to outline Reform's plans for 2024, January 3, 2024

THERE are many spectres haunting Rishi Sunak’s Tories, and the latest addition to the spectral host is the rise in the opinion polls of the Reform party.

The outfit previously trading as the Brexit Party is now apparently backed by around 10 per cent of the electorate. 

And this is without the overt involvement of its founder Nigel Farage, whose return to the political fray could increase those numbers further.

Farage is weighing up the relative advantages of political campaigning against maintaining his lucrative media career, which embraces stints in the Australian jungle and presenting on GB News.

Reform’s rise has definitely spooked a number of Tory MPs who believe, probably rightly, that its votes will come largely at their expense. Already trailing Labour massively in the polls, such defections will transfer directly into lost seats.

That does not mean that Reform is on the verge of a parliamentary breakthrough itself. In 2015 its Ukip predecessor secured nearly 13 per cent of the vote but just one seat in the Commons in an election the Tories nevertheless won.

Even the famous Farage has been unsuccessful in multiple contests in various constituencies.

But this understates the importance of Reform’s rise.  The significance doesn’t lie in its potential impact on the next election but in the durability of right-wing populism on the British political scene.

Two myths are being shattered. The first is that national populism was all about Brexit and that once Britain had left the European Union its appeal would deflate. 

Reform has simply switched to migration as its mobilising issue, with some success.

The second is that Britain is immune to the right-wing populist infection which has gained ground in many other European countries and the United States.

The Tory Party is most threatened by this. It needs to maintain the support of a base motivated by culture war confrontations while also preserving its role as the main vehicle for ruling-class interests, which currently lean towards capitalist globalisation buttressed by centrist liberalism.

Embracing the populist agenda, as championed by the party’s authoritarian deputy chairman Lee Anderson, threatens a process of Trumpifying the Conservative Party, which would alienate much Establishment opinion, not to mention centrist voters.

Yet rejecting it in the name of a more liberal Toryism can only fuel the rise of Reform. Squaring the circle — nativist neoliberalism — was the focus of the inglorious premiership of Liz Truss. 

That fiasco does not mean it will not be tried again, in the aftermath of electoral defeat. Suella Braverman waits in the wings, and Farage himself has not ruled out rejoining the Tories.

The left cannot just sit back and enjoy the spectacle. Nationalism and authoritarian politics have a base in many working-class communities, which have suffered most grievously from capitalist globalisation.

Labour in 2017 came closest to heading off this danger by championing radical social democratic policies of state intervention to improve the lives of workers and their communities, alongside an acceptance of the democratic mandate to deliver Brexit.

That allowed Labour to capture at least some ex-Ukip voters who had no time for the Tories on class grounds but insisted that the referendum decision be implemented.

That path was abandoned in 2019 with disastrous results, and it is not being followed by Keir Starmer now. His platitudinous speech today offered nothing to counter the attraction of populism to the alienated voter.

Socialists can never follow the populists in their scarcely veiled racism, their antipathy to civil liberties and their neoimperialism.  But a campaigning politics that addresses economic blight and champions popular democracy is essential if they are to be defeated.

Donate to the Fighting Fund
More from this author
US President Donald Trump gestures to the crowd as he depart
Eyes Left / 16 April 2025
16 April 2025
ANDREW MURRAY casts an eye over past upheavals and asks whether the left can find a fire escape before the world goes up in flames
Business Secretary Jonathan Reynolds outlines the draft legi
Britain / 12 April 2025
12 April 2025
But Business Secretary downplays prospect of full nationalisation and declines to extend emergency assistance to Port Talbot or Grangemouth
A Reform UK activist holds up a banner as party leader Nigel
Britain / 10 April 2025
10 April 2025
Palestinians grieve over the bodies of their relatives, who
Britain / 2 April 2025
2 April 2025
Meanwhile, Labour government toughens rhetoric against the genocide, but stops short of making any changes in policy or practical support for Israel
Similar stories
Reform UK leader Nigel Farage speaking during the Reform UK
Editorial: / 6 February 2025
6 February 2025
Dame Andrea Jenkyns, Reform UK Chairman Zia Yusuf, and Refor
Eyes Left / 10 December 2024
10 December 2024
From boozy banker renegade to man-of-the-people populist, Farage’s evolution continues — if he can win constituencies like the Welsh mining areas, the left will need new and better answers, writes ANDREW MURRAY
Nigel Farage during a press conference to announce that he w
Britain / 3 June 2024
3 June 2024