Skip to main content
Right-winger Elphicke’s defection reveals the ugly face of Starmer’s Labour
Labour leader Keir Starmer with former Conservative MP Natalie Elphicke in his parliamentary office in the House of Commons, London, May 8, 2024

NATALIE ELPHICKE’S political reincarnation as a Labour MP is an event that sheds an unforgiving light on Keir Starmer’s Labour Party.

Ms Elphicke, the MP for Dover and Deal, is no “one nation” Tory repelled by the consequences of Conservative policy.

Rather, she has sat on the right-wing edge of the Conservative Party in parliament. She has made her name as an anti-migrant hardliner, until recently attacking Labour for being “too soft” on the issue.

She inherited her Commons seat from her ex-husband Charlie Elphicke after he was charged and then imprisoned for sexual offences. She appeared to blame the victims for her then-husband’s behaviour.

She was then sanctioned by the House of Commons for attempting to put pressure on the judge presiding over Charlie’s case.

She further distinguished herself by abusing England footballer Marcus Rashford over this work to tackle the food poverty for children which has been one deplorable consequence of Tory economic and social policy.

In short, there is nothing whatever to suggest that Labour’s newest MP shares the values of the labour movement, or even of liberal Britain.

Rather, her record is that of a right-wing reprobate — indeed her statement on Wednesday indicated a strong preference for Boris Johnson over Rishi Sunak.

Yet Sir Keir rolled out the red carpet for this right-wing Tory. He welcomed her into a party which expels members for merely “liking” a tweet by a Green politician, or for expressing sympathy with a sick SNP leader.

It is a party which, moreover, has excluded Diane Abbott, Britain’s first black woman MP, from its parliamentary ranks for over a year because of a single ill-judged letter for which she immediately apologised.

A party which offers a home to Elphicke but not to Abbott is, simply, a party which is comfortable with racism.

It is not a party which is serious about tackling the glaring weaknesses in the Labour vote revealed in last week’s local elections.

How will Elphicke assist with Labour’s stated intention of winning back the tens of thousands of voters in the Muslim communities who have abandoned a party they see as not just on the wrong side of history over Gaza but also as acquiescent, to say the least, in Islamophobia?

And what will the Dover MP bring to the effort to convince young people who have voted Green or independent in so many cases to return to Labour? Her presence on the Labour benches sends the strongest possible signal that they are not wanted.

It was perfectly open to Starmer to decline to accept Elphicke’s offer to join Labour. Under those circumstances, perhaps she would have followed former Tory Party deputy chairman Lee Anderson into the Reform Party or sat as an independent.

Of course, her defection is an embarrassment for Sunak and therefore a win in the war of Westminster point-scoring. But with a gargantuan polling lead over the Tories, it is scarcely a win Starmer needs for election victory.

The fact that she wanted to join Labour shows how far the party has turned itself into a repository for right-wing opinion.

And the fact that Labour accepted her suggests that there are no limits to this transformation under its present leadership.

Indeed, a Labour spokesman declined to rule out that an approach from Nigel Farage might be welcomed, far-fetched as that suggestion doubtless is.

It is surely past time that trade union representatives on Labour’s ruling bodies raised a red flag against this process, or even the Red Flag, of equality and socialism, concepts alien to the “Labour” MP for Dover.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Similar stories
Prime Minister Keir Starmer departs 10 Downing Street, London, to attend Prime Minister's Questions at the Houses of Parliament, November 12, 2025
Labour Party / 15 November 2025
15 November 2025

As the PM and his chief of staff’s blunders have mounted up, ANDREW MURRAY wonders who among Labour’s diminished ‘soft left’ might make a bid for the leadership

Fanning the flames of fascism: Starmer’s betrayal of the working class
Features / 23 September 2025
23 September 2025

CLAUDIA WEBBE argues that Labour gains nothing from its adoption of right-wing stances on immigration, and seems instead to be deliberately paving the way for the far right to become an established force in British politics, as it has already in Europe

Reform party leader Nigel Farage takes part in media interviews after holding a news conference in central London, August 4, 2025
Features / 23 August 2025
23 August 2025

Every Starmer boast about removing asylum-seekers probably wins Reform another seat while Labour loses more voters to Lib Dems, Greens and nationalists than to the far right — the disaster facing Labour is the leadership’s fault, writes DIANE ABBOTT MP

Re your message in #nujchapel:  If we website looks like shit, no-one is going to take us seriously, or be inclined to subscribe - that's why I think we have to prioritise the way it looks, especially when the site (editorial-wise) is largely working.  When it comes to the issues you mentioned to me the other day (word count, curly quotes, bylines), there are quick and easy work arounds for them (copy and paste text into BBedit, Word, Pages, wordcount.com, etc. Leave curly quotes, bylines, etc to the web de
Democracy / 2 July 2025
2 July 2025

From Gaza complicity to welfare cuts chaos, Starmer’s baggage accumulates, and voters will indeed find ‘somewhere else’ to go — to the Greens, nationalists, Lib Dems, Reform UK or a new, working-class left party, writes NICK WRIGHT