Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Raab's Bill of Rights ‘harmful and unwelcome’, says Scottish government
Christina McKelvie MSP

DOMINIC RAAB’S shake-up of human rights laws is “harmful and unwelcome,” the Scottish government said at the weekend. 

In a searing attack on the Justice Secretary’s plans to scrap the Human Rights Act and replace it with a new Bill of rights, Holyrood warned that the proposals would also interfere with Scotland’s constitution. 

The new legislation, which is due to receive its first reading in Parliament on September 12, seeks to reduce the influence of the European Courts of Human Rights in domestic courts. 

Human rights groups have described the overhaul as a “power grab” and an attempt by the government to make itself “untouchable.”

Responding to a call for evidence from Westminister’s joint committee on human rights, Scotland’s Equalities Minister Christina McKelvie warned that the plans would do “serious harm to fundamental freedoms in Britain. 

“The Scottish government has repeatedly said that there must be no changes to the Human Rights Act that undermine or weaken existing human rights protections,” said. 

“The UK does not need a new ‘Bill of rights.’ That role is already very successfully performed by the Human Rights Act, which has a 20-year track record of delivering justice, including for some of the most vulnerable people in our society.”

She added: “The Bill of Rights Bill is ill conceived and unwelcome. Some of the provisions are confusing and contradictory.

“It interferes with the constitutional settlement in Scotland by legislating for devolved matters, undermining the Scottish Parliament and Scotland’s devolution settlement.

“The Scottish government remains committed to protecting the Human Rights Act in its current form.”

A spokesman for the British government asserted that the proposals would strengthen human rights and “inject a healthy dose of common sense to curb the abuse of human rights.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
People take part in a Million Women Rise march outside Chari
Britain / 4 March 2023
4 March 2023
Million Women Rise call out state failures to tackle misogyny and racism in society
Similar stories
Features / 8 February 2025
8 February 2025
PROFESSOR ANSELM ELDERGILL explains why this new piece of government legislation is giving cause for concern
Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar
Features / 29 August 2024
29 August 2024
Plans to change the law to give the Scottish Secretary of State powers to bypass the Scottish Parliament to directly fund ‘anti-poverty schemes’ could provoke an unwelcome crisis for Anas Sarwar, argues VINCE MILLS