Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Post-devolution economic policy more ‘style rather than substance’, say experts
A Saltire flag is flanked by Union flags flying above Whitehall in Westminster, London

ECONOMIC policy in Scotland has hardly changed in 25 years of devolution, according to a new expert paper today.

Looking at post-devolution economic policy, the paper’s authors — Glasgow University economics professor and Scottish Fiscal Commission chairman, Graeme Roy, Glasgow University lecturer David Waite, and Strathclyde University’s Andrew Goudie — found a “remarkable degree of similarity” in approach in economic policy since 1999.

They argued: “Scotland remains in the bottom OECD quartile for international exports as a share of GDP.”

The group found that a “lack of scrutiny on what has worked and what has not worked is particularly noteworthy” and branded post-devolution economic policy “rather timid.”

They concluded:  “One is left with the impression of the economics of devolution as often being focused upon style rather than substance.”

SNP deputy First Minister Kate Forbes responded: “Scotland’s trade and competitiveness has been hit by the loss of the full and free access it once had to the European single market.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
A Saltire flag is flanked by Union flags flying above Whiteh
Britain / 19 March 2025
19 March 2025
Prime Minister Keir Starmer and Home Secretary Yvette Cooper
Britain / 5 November 2024
5 November 2024