Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
Not for the likes of us? Oh yes, they are
LYNNE WALSH takes issue with the idea that the arts aren't for 'ordinary people'
A dress rehearsal of Opera North's Madama Butterfly

 

“RUGBY union is a middle-class sport,” a leftie friend told me recently. I should prefer football, he insisted, which is “working-class opera.”


Now, apart from repudiating his daft claim — as a rugby fan, I’m an old Arms Park groundling, rather than a Twickers toff — he got me thinking. Why isn’t opera “working class”?


Vox pops on the topic were called for, so I stood outside the Lidl supermarket in Feltham, my regular choice for such journalistic groundwork, where you get a decent cross-section of the public. Remarks like: “It’s never about real life, is it? It’s always royalty” and “No-one writes operas and plays about ordinary people,” seem to sum up the resistance to what's on offer in our theatres.


Those views are not true, of course. Reviewing shows over the last year, I've seen performances about friends falling out, lovers cheating and teenagers struggling to find their way. True, there was one about Napoleon but even that reminded me of my first editor at the Rhondda Leader.


Still, negative stereotypes are enough to keep us from trying an experience. Is there a class divide, tainting people’s expectations of the arts? Some social commentators would have us believe that few define themselves as working class, now that we’re all fooled by social bloody mobility. Is this a class question at all?

 

I recall my response to the theatre version of the film Rita, Sue and Bob Too which I reviewed for the Morning Star a few months ago. The bleak lives of its working-class characters seemed played for laughs and it felt cartoon-like.
 

I came away, grumpily looking up a quote from writer Tim Lott, who’d used, in the Guardian, an extraordinary phrase which stuck with me. Pondering on working-class writers, he’d said: “There are no writers out there any more to bring us bulletins from the lives of what is probably the largest single group in society.”


Who, in the name of arse, is the “us” in that statement? Is it the middle and upper classes who consume and enjoy the arts and rely on “bulletins” to inform on the lives of others?


In the same piece he cited the late novelist Alan Sillitoe, thereby hammering home the old stereotype, when in fact the writer rejected labels. I check with his son, David, who tells me: “He didn’t like the ‘working class’ label. He told me 'an artist has no class' and he didn’t want to ally himself with any school of thought. He just did what he did, popular or not.”


Discovering Sillitoe’s work was for me an entry point to many more novels and films. Reading The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner, aged about 10, was a revelation — this voice resonated even more than Dylan Thomas’s had.


In more recent years — my Welsh bias showing — I’d look to the works of Rachel Tresize, whose stories are harrowing and witty. Last year, she wrote We’re Still Here, about the threatened closure of Port Talbot steelworks, basing it on interviews with workers, union reps and local people.

 

And then there's playwright Gary Owen — Welsh, too — the author of Killology, with its victims of an exploitative economy and Iphigenia in Splott, a scream of anger against the impact of austerity. Its unlikely heroine was played by Sophie Melville, a fine young actress, who says she didn’t think theatre would be her calling because it might be too posh and she wouldn’t understand it. I’m glad she got over that idea.


Owen studied at Cambridge. “I’d never really moved outside a working-class context before, it wasn’t a place I fitted in with very well,” he tells me. “Now I work in a very ‘rarefied’ profession but the work isn’t, because I write about real people.”


He’s currently working on a new play, also set in Splott. Judging by his previous output, I think my neighbours in Feltham would like it.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Caroline Darian / Pic: Olivier Roller
Features / 6 June 2025
6 June 2025

Caroline Darian, daughter of Gisele Pelicot, took part in a conversation with Afua Hirsch at London’s Royal Geographical Society. LYNNE WALSH reports 

Demonstrators during an anti-racism protest organised by Sta
Antifascism / 7 May 2025
7 May 2025

This year’s Bristol Radical History Festival focused on the persistent threats of racism, xenophobia and, of course, our radical collective resistance to it across Ireland and Britain, reports LYNNE WALSH 

Lynne Walsh piece webpic.jpg
Features / 22 April 2025
22 April 2025

LYNNE WALSH previews the Bristol Radical History Conference this weekend

REMARKABLE: The Danish writer Karen Blixen as a recipient of
International Women's Day 2025 / 8 March 2025
8 March 2025
With most of recorded history dominated by the voices of men, LYNNE WALSH encourages sisters to read the memoirs of women – and to write their own too
Similar stories
Firefox ridden by Sam Ewing on their way to winning the Mong
Horse racing / 12 March 2025
12 March 2025
Joyeuse ridden by James Bowen (left) passes Tutti Quanti rid
Horse racing / 8 February 2025
8 February 2025
Our tipster gives this weekend's lowdown
Calandagan ridden by Stephane Pasquier on their way to winni
Horse racing / 19 October 2024
19 October 2024
Our tipster looks at the best offerings from Ascot, York
Japan's Naomi Osaka returns a shot against Italy's Lucia Bro
Women’s Tennis / 25 September 2024
25 September 2024