Skip to main content
Advertise Buy the paper Contact us Shop Subscribe Support us
Holst: the socialist composer and his (accidental) patriotic smash hit
MAT COWARD unearths Gustav Holst’s radical roots, from meetings at William Morris’s house to pamphlet-printing and agitation with the Red Vicar of Thaxted — and laments that he is remembered today for the entirely wrong reason

LEADER of the Can’t Sing Choir, pioneer of musical education for women, close collaborator with the notorious Red Vicar of Thaxted, involuntary composer of I Vow to Thee, My Country, and composer of Britain’s most recorded piece of music ever, Gustavus von Holst was born in Cheltenham on September 21, into a family of musicians and music teachers.

In his teens, he was employed as an organist and choirmaster. Physical frailties forced him to abandon the piano and take up the trombone instead. Earnings from that financed his studies in composition.

Except for one or two brief sabbaticals, paid for by wealthy patrons, Holst never worked as a full-time composer. To the very end of his life, he taught music at private schools, and for much of it, he was variously a trombonist in orchestras and theatres, college lecturer, church organist and choir leader.

Holst encountered socialist ideas when he moved to London in the 1890s. He attended meetings at William Morris’s house, where George Bernard Shaw and Morris himself were among the speakers. It was in his capacity as conductor of the Hammersmith Socialist Choir that Holst met his future wife, Isobel.

On the choir’s processions, Holst would sit in a cart playing the harmonium. He taught at a college for working people, too, and took his choirs to the slums of the East End.

He made gradual progress as a composer during the next few years, but it’s in 1914 that he really enters Rebel Britannia’s purview. Refused for any sort of war service due to his lifelong poor health, and possibly because of his Teutonic name, he continued his habit of going on country walks with fellow composer Ralph Vaughan Williams in pursuit of one of their great mutual interests, English folk songs.

In the small town or large village of Thaxted, Essex, one day in 1913, they had entered the local church to discover that it was decorated with the Sinn Fein banner and the Red Flag of revolution. As Holst subsequently learned, the vicar, Conrad Noel, had forbidden the Union Flag from his workplace on the grounds that it represented imperialism and belonged to the financiers.

The Reverend Noel, his extraordinary battles with the church authorities, and the remarkable people he gathered around him in Thaxted, must be a separate story. For now, we can say simply that Holst had found his true home.

His close friendship with Noel led to the village becoming a famous centre of music, as well as of revolutionary socialism.

He became closely involved with Noel’s church on the choral side, and would at other times be found cycling around the area delivering copies of socialist newspapers. He and Noel also operated a press together, producing pamphlets such as Is Jesus the Revolutionary Leader?

As a man, and as a composer, Holst had numerous interests: Hindu mysticism, English poetry and folklore, dance and ritual, and Tudor and Elizabethan music. It was curiosity about astrology which led to his most famous work, The Planets, a seven-movement orchestral suite written during the first world war.

Some critics were horrified by the sometimes startling novelty of Holst’s work, and reviews condemned it as merely “noisy.” But it quite quickly became one of the nation’s favourite orchestral compositions; it’s reckoned that no other piece by a British composer has been recorded so many times.

Holst wasn’t a notably cheerful bloke, and celebrity brought him little pleasure. He simply hid from it whenever he could.

When the town of his birth held a Holst Festival, he escaped it by going on a walking holiday in Yorkshire. The Royal College of Music did manage to elect him as a Fellow, but only by not telling him in advance that they were going to do it.

He carried on working — both at the day jobs (his contemporaries said he was as great a teacher as he was a composer, with his emphasis on practical music-making), and taking on far too many commissions to write music for military bands, schools and choirs.

His health, always bad, got worse. Having undergone a successful operation for a duodenal ulcer in May 1934, he died of heart failure days later.

If The Planets is what Holst is remembered for, then within that suite, it’s movement four, Jupiter, the Bringer of Jollity, which is perhaps most familiar.

Based on it is the much-loved, much-despised hymn I Vow to Thee, My Country, a controversially martial and nationalistic poem written by a retired diplomat. Holst agreed to the pairing of words and music, and apparently regretted doing so for the rest of his life.

The idea that patriotism is “the love that asks no questions” could hardly be further from the beliefs of Holst or the sermons of Noel. Holst’s own name for the tune, minus its objectionable lyrics, was Thaxted — which seems a lot more appropriate and, somehow, a lot more English.

You can sign up for Mat Coward’s Rebel Britannia Substack at www.rebelbrit.substack.com for more strange strikes, peculiar protests, bizarre boycotts, unusual uprisings and different demos.

More from this author
Features / 20 November 2024
20 November 2024
MAT COWARD explores how the ‘Tory-Radical’ Christian minister became a fiery opponent of the Poor Law, advocating armed resistance against its brutal cruelty against the emerging working class
Crime fiction / 19 November 2024
19 November 2024
Daring Scottish gothic, a murderer in their midst, the best spy story of the year and a classic list of clues
Features / 14 November 2024
14 November 2024
Taking up social work after being widowed transformed a Victorian liberal into a lifelong fighter for causes as wide-ranging as Sinn Fein and Indian independence to the right of women to drink in pubs, writes MAT COWARD
Gardening / 9 November 2024
9 November 2024
MAT COWARD declares this plant to be one that ‘everyone should grow’
Similar stories
Features / 20 November 2024
20 November 2024
MAT COWARD explores how the ‘Tory-Radical’ Christian minister became a fiery opponent of the Poor Law, advocating armed resistance against its brutal cruelty against the emerging working class
Marxist Notes on Music / 19 November 2024
19 November 2024
BEN LUNN draws attention to the way cultural expressions of solidarity with Palestinians in the UK are being censored by Israeli-sponsored lawfare
Theatre Review / 26 March 2024
26 March 2024
GORDON PARSONS is thrilled by the dramatisation of the relationship between a gay composer and his unmarried female assistant
Culture / 22 January 2024
22 January 2024
Time to celebrate Gustav Holst, an innovator who helped bring brass band instruments into the orchestra and wrote for working-class musicians