Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Government 'throwing good money after bad' in probation privateer bailout
Justice Secretary David Gauke has let failing private community rehabilitation companies off the hook - costing the taxpayer hundreds of millions

THE GOVERNMENT’s decision to bail out failing private probation companies again was branded “disgusting” and dismissed as “throwing good money after bad”, by unions, MPs and charities today.

Former justice secretary Chris Grayling’s shambolic Transforming Rehabilitation privatisation agenda set up 21 community rehabilitation companies (CRCs) to manage low-risk offenders, despite widespread opposition to the plans.

The contracts, signed in 2014, were due to run until 2022, but Mr Grayling’s successor David Gauke has announced that the government’s contracts with eight CRCs will end two years early.

The bailout will cost £170 million, including £110m in fines owed by the CRCs to the Ministry of Justice for poor performance but which they will be allowed to reinvest instead.

With the extra £342m that the government has already had to dole out to the CRCs, the taxpayer is now more than £500m out of pocket.

Shadow justice secretary Richard Burgon said the decision represented “further evidence that the Conservatives’ decision to outsource whole swathes of probation to the private sector has created an unprecedented crisis in the system.”

He blasted the Tories’ “ideological experiment” as a “costly failure” and pledged that, under Labour, “there will be no more bailouts for failing private probation companies.”

Mr Burgon also described the decision to hold back the embarrassing announcement until the parliamentary recess as “a tacit admission by the government that its probation policies can’t withstand the slightest scrutiny.”

Napo general secretary Ian Lawrence dismissed the announcement as “a desperate attempt” to prop up Mr Grayling’s failed policy, and said it was “disgusting” that private companies received taxpayers’ cash “while our members wait seven years for a pay rise.”

He said the Tories remain “wedded to a failed and unworkable ideology, and cannot accept the undeniable fact that justice and public safety cannot be subject to the rule of supply and demand.”

Shadow chancellor John McDonnell observed that, after “another disaster by Grayling,” the now Transport Secretary should “never be allowed near any government office.”

Howard League for Penal Reform chief executive Frances Crook said Mr Grayling’s policy had failed and “the mess created by the public/private split of probation was foreseeable and was foreseen.”

She welcomed the government’s admission that the policy needed urgent change, but added: “Handing over more cash in the meantime to abject private companies, whose contracts are being cut short because they have failed to deliver what was promised, is throwing good money after bad.”

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Britain / 17 June 2021
17 June 2021
All eight claimants say Labour acted unfairly by failing to close investigations or revoke their suspension or expulsion
Similar stories
CHANGE SLOW TO COME: Scotland Justice Secretary Angela Constance (SNP) meets prison officers during a visit the new HMP and YOI Stirling
Probation Service / 30 May 2025
30 May 2025

IAN LAWRENCE welcomes the government sentencing review but warns past experience shows such words rarely translate into meaningful action

A view of HMP Northeye in Bexhill-on-Sea, East Sussex, which
Britain / 15 November 2024
15 November 2024
Government urged to put ‘clear distance between it and the cruel, wasteful camps policy held by the previous one’
TUC Congress 2024 / 10 September 2024
10 September 2024
Napo is calling for urgent funding from the new Labour government, directed at the front line, to address 14 years of Tory neglect of a vital service and alleviate the stress on hardworking probation officers, says TANIA BASSETT