Skip to main content
We need to defend CalMac
It is not the public ownership model that is failing Scotland’s ferry services, it is the government’s poor management – and privatisation would be far worse, writes KATY CLARK MSP

THIS time last year, I wrote that Scotland’s public ferry service was in crisis due to the “failure of the Scottish government to invest in a new fleet over many years,” with sailings cancelled at short notice due to technical breakdowns.

Since then, matters have spiralled out of control.

On Arran, islanders faced food and fuel shortages over the winter due to unreliable sailings. In South Uist, hundreds of residents have been turning out in recent days to protest their service being withdrawn due to difficulties elsewhere on the network.

Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
tototototototdo
More from this author
tototototototdo
Voices of Scotland / 12 February 2025
12 February 2025
Locals have been let down by procrastination over the upgrade to Ardrossan Harbour, says KATY CLARK MSP
tototototototdo
Voices of Scotland / 23 July 2024
23 July 2024
Years of underfunding and hollow promises have pushed college staff to breaking point — the Scottish government must recognise further education as a vital public good deserving proper support, writes KATY CLARK MSP
tototototototdo
Voices of Scotland / 12 December 2023
12 December 2023
We need genuine freedom of information legislation in Scotland to hold our government and all public bodies accountable, writes KATY CLARK MSP, introducing a new campaign
tototototototdo
Voices of Scotland / 28 November 2022
28 November 2022
KATY CLARK MSP salutes the groundbreaking legislation that allows us to scrutinise those that govern us — but argues it is now outdated, and introduces her new Bill which aims to bring the system up to date
Similar stories
tototototototdo
Britain / 19 March 2025
19 March 2025
tototototototdo
Aw That / 18 January 2025
18 January 2025
Mismanagement, privatisation and EU rules have strangled vital ferry services, leaving Scotland’s island communities stranded and the once-bustling ports of my youth in what feels like terminal decline, laments MATT KERR
tototototototdo
Britain / 13 January 2025
13 January 2025
tototototototdo
STUC Congress 2024 / 15 April 2024
15 April 2024
From defending Scotland’s ticket offices to making the case for a People’s CalMac, my union will be standing firm across the rail and maritime industries, says MICK LYNCH