Skip to main content
Donate to the 95 years appeal
Climate change: the Conservatives ignore the burning question
Why was there almost no overlap in this week's major news events: the Tory leadership race and the hottest days on record? Because the party of small-mindedness and big business has nothing but contempt for our planet, writes ALAN SIMPSON

BRITAIN swelters in an unprecedented heatwave. Tens of thousands of people across Europe flee from fires that defy public control.

The climate change committee reports that Britain is falling behind in its existing climate commitments. And scientists warn that even if we meet the 1.5°C target, this month’s heatwaves are likely to become the summer norm.

You would have thought all this would have made avoiding climate breakdown the centrepiece debate among Conservative contenders to become prime minister.

It is a measure of the crisis we are in that “climate” is being forced into the debate by interviewers and commentators rather than the candidates themselves.

I never thought there was anything I’d be thankful to Boris Johnson for, but the leadership debacle sparked by his resignation has thrown the paucity of Conservative leadership into stark relief. One after another, Tory hopefuls have been demonstrating that the party as a whole is unfit to govern.

It isn’t just that some candidates are being funded by climate-denying lobby groups or by fossil fuel interests. The entire debate remains fraudulent or self-deluding.

The fight doesn’t revolve around targets for 2050 or later. Everything will be determined by what we do within the current decade. So even Conservative candidates who claim to support net-zero commitments struggle to explain why they back policies that would do the opposite.

These range from permits for further North Sea oil exploration, expanding aviation, excluding climate targets in trade deals, axing home energy efficiency programmes, dumping the zero-carbon homes standard, through to support for new coalmines, fracking and road building.

If you thought Johnson was just a naked opportunist, take a long look at the nakedness that is set to follow. All the wannabe Tory leaders adhere to a belief that the policies that took us into today’s crises are precisely the ones needed to rescue us.

The contest is no better than a bunch of drunks arguing about whose turn it is to ride the bicycle. Each is a disaster waiting to happen.

Taxing times

Arguments about tax cutting are the most obvious starting point. The most right-wing Tory candidates insist that dogmatic manifesto pledges must override the economic and existential crises.

Almost certainly none of the hopefuls will have read Tim Jackson’s prescient book Prosperity Without Growth written back in 2009, which outlined a different framework of sustainable economics. None grasps that circularity will become more important than productivity. None understands that the economics of repair must replace those of self-reward.

Instead, Tory obsessions with globalised trade, conventional growth and deregulated markets litter the political jousting areas. None of the hopefuls even mentions that billionaire wealth in Britain has grown by £1 billion a week over the last year and has increased progressively throughout the last decade. This wealth now stands at over £700bn.

The lives of the super-rich go untouched by the cost-of-living crisis. But a simple 3 per cent tax on individual wealth over £10bn would raise enough money to pay all today’s public service pay claims and put the money into domestic circulation rather than speculative acquisition.

Moreover, in his last Budget, Rishi Sunak squirrelled new tax subsidies of between £2.7bn and £5.7bn into the pockets of oil companies.

Even the lower figure, if put into a national energy efficiency programme, would have saved £700m in annual household energy bills. The trouble is that this isn’t what Johnson’s successors are squabbling about.

Net-zero to not zero

Everything we have neglected, weakened or destroyed in the past is catching up with us at a rate that will overwhelm economic orthodoxies. Much of what will be classed as “wild weather” has ramifications that will redefine national, international and local priorities like nothing else before.

Even before fires raged across western France, the country faced severe losses in this year’s wheat production. Wild weather is forecast to reduce yields by 25 per cent.

Italy has just declared a national drought emergency. Its harvests of olives, grapes and grains are all under threat. Heatwaves in India and Pakistan are causing crop losses and grain shortages that will kick on to food pricing. Only Russia seems to be the beneficiary of a bigger harvest.

The US fares no better. California’s largest reservoirs are at their lowest ever levels. Arizona’s Glen Canyon dam (the second largest in the US) is locked into a 22-year drought, threatening the water supplies of over 40 million people.

If its water level drops by another 32ft the dam’s turbines, producing electricity for the region, will also cease. No amount of productivity improvements will put this right.

But before the region’s lights go out (and household taps dry up) a civil war will break out. Municipalities, indigenous tribes and multinationals will go to war over the 80 per cent of the water supply currently taken by agribusiness. It won’t be a pretty sight.

One way or another, climate is the only place for today's politics to start. Yet not a single Conservative leadership candidate will say this.

Blaming Ben & Jerry

Before she fell out of the leadership race, Suella Braverman probably summed up what most of her party believes.

Speaking at a business gathering, Braverman lambasted the “Ben & Jerry environmentalism” surrounding food and production policies. For her, crude profiteering is all that matters.

Kemi Badenoch MP went further, describing climate commitments as acts of “unilateral economic disarmament.”

The frightening thing is that this can’t just be put down to a couple of loopy MPs who have lost the plot. Behind it lies a much bigger, scarier disconnect.

Alan Simpson was Labour MP for Nottingham South from 1992 to 2010.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
Prime Minister Keir Starmer leaves the end of a press conference on the Immigration White Paper in the Downing Street Briefing Room in London, May 12, 2025
Features / 19 May 2025
19 May 2025

ALAN SIMPSON warns that Starmer’s triangulation strategy will fail just as New Labour’s did, with each rightward move by Labour pushing Tories further right

Franklyn Roosevelt, November 1932
The Futurue / 2 May 2025
2 May 2025

ALAN SIMPSON warns of a dystopian crossroads where Trump’s wrecking ball meets AI-driven alienation, and argues only a Green New Deal can repair our fractured society before techno-feudalism consumes us all

US President Donald Trump stands in the presidential box as
Features / 20 March 2025
20 March 2025
As the ‘NRx movement’ plots to replace democracy with corporate-feudal dictatorship, Britain must pursue a radical alternative of local food security and genuine wealth redistribution to withstand the coming upheaval, writes ALAN SIMPSON
MODERN FEUDALISM:
New US President Donald
Trump
Features / 30 January 2025
30 January 2025
Some hard political choices must be made in Trump’s post-truth era – starting by abandoning any illusions about the ‘special relationship’ and waking up to the need for bold policy-making on the climate, argues ALAN SIMPSON
Similar stories
STANDS TO REASON: Climate change protest in Whitehall, centr
Features / 2 December 2024
2 December 2024
Undaunted by Big Oil success, ALAN SIMPSON looks at alternatives to lack of courage and imagination stifling the Labour government and it policies
 A volunteer rests during a clean-up in an area affected by
Features / 1 November 2024
1 November 2024
As deadly weather events spread death and destruction, ALAN SIMPSON argues that Labour’s first Budget has failed to address the converging crises of climate breakdown and democratic alienation that require transformative change
An aerial view showing a flooded New Road Cricket ground in
Editorial: / 21 October 2024
21 October 2024
Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer speaks during a press confer
Features / 9 July 2024
9 July 2024
From nationalising public services, taxes on the rich, dropping tuition fees to green investment, the new PM’s abandoned promises raise doubts about Labour’s real commitment to its promises for ‘change,’ writes PETER KENWORTHY