Skip to main content
Morning Star Conference
Britain at Christmas: From Scrooge to universal credit

WHILE the mainstream media chunter and engage in magical thinking about Brexit, for many in the other Britain, far away from the concerns of Westminster — except when Jeremy Corbyn occasionally forces Tory MPs to face the impact of their own policies — it is set to be a miserable Christmas.

The workhouse has long since been abolished, but rough sleeping on the streets continues to rise. Meanwhile the impact of universal credit means that even those in work find themselves having to use foodbanks to live.

This situation has arisen as a direct result of Tory and Liberal Democrat policies since 2010, and from 2015 just the Tory Party of David Cameron and Theresa May. Yet they did not think up the ideas about how to make life miserable for the poor themselves. Rather they have been implemented at times of economic crisis since the 19th century.

The 1834 Poor Law Amendment Act, which was the work of economic liberals, now known as neoliberals, was carried through by a Whig (Liberal) government.

It was strongly opposed at the time. The workhouse was its symbol but underneath lay a philosophy. That was known as the less eligibility principle — namely, that if you could not earn enough to live on yourself, the state would provide a basic subsistence. However that provision would always be less pleasant and tougher than even the hardest job with the longest hours.

Charles Dickens wrote his bestselling book A Christmas Carol for the festive season of 1843 less than 10 years after the introduction of the workhouse.

In the book the city financier Ebeneezer Scrooge is visited by ghosts and he sees the error of his ways in how he was treating his clerk Bob Cratchit. That was Dickens’s desired conclusion and a suitably uplifting tale for Christmas.

However, his description of Scrooge’s views early in the book reflect the realities of attitudes in the early Victorian City of London (Scrooge’s office was in Cornhill near the Bank of England).

Scrooge is visited by “two portly gentlemen” seeking to collect funds for the poor at Christmas. They tell him that “many thousands are in want of common necessaries; hundreds of thousands are in want of common comforts.”

Scrooge asks the charity collectors if by some chance the workhouses and prisons are no longer operating. He goes on to make it clear that he will be contributing nothing to the less well-off at Christmas: “I don’t make myself merry at Christmas and I can’t afford to make idle people merry. I help to support the establishments I have mentioned” (prisons and workhouses); “they cost enough: and those who are badly off must go there.”

The 2018 equivalent would perhaps to be to collect for Crisis at Christmas or for a foodbank. Scrooge’s view was that the misfortunes of the poor were entirely their own fault and it is not difficult to spot very similar views among Tory MPs when Jeremy Corbyn raises the situation of the those in need in the Commons.

In recent weeks Tory MPs, including the architect of universal credit Iain Duncan Smith, have been pictured smiling at foodbanks. Clearly for media image purposes they have taken Dickens’s conclusion to a Christmas Carol on board — that at Christmas the harsh words and practices of neoliberalism are abandoned for a more benevolent approach.

The reality is, however, that Christmas 2018 will be just as tough for many who are at the wrong end of market capitalism as it was in 1843 when Dickens’s book appeared.

 

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
WINNING OVER THE WORKING CLASS? Margaret Thatcher (left) personally sells off a London council house in her bid to undermine the welfare state and woo Labour voters via the 1980 Housing Act and so-called ‘right to buy’ for tenants
Features / 26 May 2025
26 May 2025

Research shows Farage mainly gets rebel voters from the Tory base and Labour loses voters to the Greens and Lib Dems — but this doesn’t mean the danger from the right isn’t real, explains historian KEITH FLETT

Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch at their local election campaign launch at The Curzon Centre in Beaconsfield, Buckinghamshire, March 20, 2025
Features / 14 May 2025
14 May 2025

KEITH FLETT traces how the ‘world’s most successful political party’ has imploded since Thatcher’s fall, from nine leaders in 30 years to losing all 16 English councils, with Reform UK symbolically capturing Peel’s birthplace, Tamworth — but the beast is not dead yet

STILL MARCHING: A May Day demo makes its way through London, 1973
Features / 1 May 2025
1 May 2025

KEITH FLETT revisits the 1978 origins of Britain’s May Day bank holiday — from Michael Foot’s triumph to Thatcher’s reluctant acceptance — as Starmer’s government dodges calls to expand our working-class celebrations

Features / 14 April 2025
14 April 2025
From bemoaning London’s ‘cockneys’ invading seaside towns to negotiating holiday rents, the founders of scientific socialism maintained a wry detachment from Victorian Easter customs while using the break for health and politics, writes KEITH FLETT
Similar stories
Jonathan Hanks in A Christmas Carol
Theatre Review / 23 December 2024
23 December 2024
SUSAN DARLINGTON enjoys, with minor reservations, the Northern Ballet’s revival of its 1992 classic
Oliver Twist asks for more
Features / 9 December 2024
9 December 2024
From Raab to Rees-Mogg, STEPHEN ARNELL observes how modern Conservatives yearn for the return of the brutal institutions where the poor were imprisoned and punished for their plight
VICTORIAN MORALITY FOR KIDS: A Christmas Carol at Sherman Th
Theatre review / 27 November 2024
27 November 2024
DAVID NICHOLSON, eight-year-old BEHATI and nine-year-old SKYLAR applaud a hilarious production that doesn’t ignore the social message
NOTHING TO LOSE BUT CHAINS: Scrooge (John Simm) confronts hi
Theatre review / 25 November 2024
25 November 2024
PAUL DONOVAN applauds the dogged determination of the Old Vic to stage Dickens’s classic Christmas moral tale in support of Waterloo food bank