Skip to main content
Gifts from The Morning Star
Peers reject Patel's proposals to offshore asylum-seekers in latest blow to her anti-refugee Bill
Home Secretary Priti Patel during a National Crime Agency operation at address in east London

HOME SECRETARY Priti Patel’s proposals to offshore asylum-seekers have been rejected by peers in the latest blow to her anti-refugee Bill. 

The House of Lords voted by 208 to 155 — a majority of 53 — to scrap a provision in the Nationality and Borders Bill which would open the door to Australia-style offshore processing centres for refugees. 

The policy was condemned by Lords across all parties, with Tory peer Baroness Stroud branding it “unworkable on numerous levels,” saying it would expose “vulnerable people to further trauma rather than offering protection.” 

It comes after peers threw out some of the central policies of Ms Patel’s asylum reforms earlier in the week, putting the Bill further at risk. 

Refugee rights campaigners today welcomed the House of Lords resistance to the Bill. 

Refugee Council CEO Enver Solomon said: “These amendments will mean men, women and children fleeing bloodshed and war, like those from Ukraine, will not be criminalised for needing protection. 

“Nor treated with great cruelty by having the door slammed in their face and sent off to have their claims processed in offshore facilities overseas.”

Freedom from Torture chief executive Sonya Sceats described the vote as “another huge victory for compassion.” 

“It is utterly unconscionable for ministers to be pushing through legislation that would lead to Ukrainian and other refugees being penalised with offshore imprisonment simply for making their own way to safety in the UK,” she said. 

“Torture survivors we would otherwise treat at Freedom from Torture would be at risk of forced removal under these cruel proposals.”

The Tories lost all eight votes held on the second day of the Bill’s report stage in the Lords on Wednesday evening.   

Peers also voted to open a new safe route for unaccompanied child refugees in Europe to be reunited with family in Britain, an amendment tabled by Labour peer Lord Alf Dubs. 

Safe Passage International CEO Beth Gardiner-Smith said that the route would be a “lifeline” for refugee children stranded in Calais and squalid Greek refugee camps. 
 
“Next MPs must listen and vote to protect unaccompanied refugee children when this Bill returns to the House of Commons in the coming weeks,” she urged. 

The changes by peers will then go back to the Commons, where MPs can approve or reject them. 

Peers also voted to scrap a provision making it an offence to knowingly arrive in Britain without permission.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
More from this author
People take part in a Million Women Rise march outside Chari
Britain / 4 March 2023
4 March 2023
Million Women Rise call out state failures to tackle misogyny and racism in society
Similar stories
Lord Alf Dubs on stage addressing the crowd during a rally in Parliament Square, London, after taking part in the Refugees Welcome March, September 2016
Features / 6 May 2025
6 May 2025

A recent Immigration Summit heard from Lord Alf Dubs, who fled the Nazis to Britain as a child. JAYDEE SEAFORTH reports on his message that we need to increase public empathy with desperate people seeking asylum

 Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer
Britain / 31 March 2025
31 March 2025
Starmer's ‘Organised Immigration Crime Summit’ fails to find the simple solution to upend human smugglers’ business model: safe routes
A view of HMP Northeye in Bexhill-on-Sea, East Sussex, March
Britain / 5 February 2025
5 February 2025
MPs condemn Home Office after it wasted £15.4m on derelict prison to house asylum seekers