Skip to main content
The Morning Star Shop
The real struggle is to liberate our class
The trade union movement remains the strongest force for a better Scotland for all, argues RICHARD LEONARD

"It is an abiding and indisputable truth that a people which does not understand the past will never comprehend the present, nor mould the future."

So wrote Tom Johnston in his foreword to the 1946 edition of The History of the Working Classes in Scotland.

Johnston's powerful message echoes down the years and so it was fitting that it was recalled at the start of a special labour history workshop last Saturday at the Glasgow Museums Resource Centre.

The workshop focused on trade union and co-operative banners held in the Glasgow museums archives. It was a celebration of working-class history which is not remembered enough.

Through these banners it is possible to see popular art vividly displayed, often with humour and always with high idealism.

Among the archives on display was the Yarrow Joint Shop Stewards Committee banner from the days even before the Upper Clyde shipbuilders' work-in, the Co-operative Women's Guild banner from the oldest guild in the country - Kinning Park in Glasgow - and two which centred around disputes from the mid 1980s, the Caterpillar Joint Occupation Committee banner and the Morris Furniture Timber and Allied Trades banner. The testimony of the rank-and-file trade union leaders from both of these disputes was in turn moving and instructive.

The Caterpillar workers occupied their factory in Lanarkshire for 103 days at the start of 1987 when the US owners announced their intention to shut the factory just days after substantial state and corporate capital investment had been pledged.

In 1985 35 Morris Furniture workers in Glasgow were summarily dismissed and locked out of their factory after taking action for a return to the National Labour Agreement standard 39-hour week.

They picketed the factory for two years before setting up their own workers' co-operative.

In both cases these heroic trade unionists laid to rest the myth that workers cannot run industry. The inner confidence of a group of working people was boosted, unleashing creativity and huge productive potential.

It is precisely for this reason that history demands that we reawaken our interest in industrial and a wider economic democracy. It was Keir Hardie, Labour's first and greatest leader, who wrote in his seminal 1907 tract From Serfdom to Socialism that "socialism represents the same principle in industry which radicalism represented in politics - equality."

In contrast the SNP's white paper Scotland's Future fails to mention industrial democracy or co-operatives and merely promises a consultation about employee representation on company boards post-independence.

It is noteworthy that the example which is cited, the London Stock Exchange-listed First Group, does indeed have an employee director, but that director has to resign any position in the trade union, pledge loyalty and confidentiality to the board and can be vetoed by the company. This is not industrial democracy. Far from it.

What we need is a genuine transfer of power within industry and the economy.

And that's what the Red Paper Collective is calling for. Because it is clear that the decisive struggle is not on the national question but on the class question.

The real division in society is not between Scotland and England but between working people and the idle rich.

It is not the so-called "Westminster system" invoked by those in the Yes campaign peddling an instant road to socialism, but the capitalist economic system which needs to be tackled.

Economic relations determine power relations so that requires us to organise, put pressure on the state and win political power at the level where that economic power rests, not break away from it. There are no shortcuts.

The distribution of power is not simply a question of geography and territory.

Of course a line can be drawn through this small shared island and a nation-state of Scotland declared independent from the rest.

Indeed this is summoned up in an attempt to persuade Labour supporters to vote Yes because it will get rid of the Tories forever. The trouble is a Yes vote won't open up possibilities for fundamental economic and social transformation, it will close them down.

Indeed worse still under the SNP's preferred option of a shared currency Scotland's interest rates, exchange rates, public debt ratio, employment and inflation targets will be set by the Bank of England and the "Rest of UK" Exchequer over which the people of Scotland will no longer have any control or representation. Far from banishing the Tories it will hand power over to them.

One of the other illusions on the Yes side of the debate is that this is a colonial liberation struggle with parallels to India in the 1940s, as though Scotland is somehow a colony or dominion of the British empire.

Well, I can't think of another colonised nation providing so many leaders for the colonising nation as Scotland has, from Campbell Bannerman and Bonar Law to Gordon Brown.

The irony here is that if the SNP has its way Scotland will have its financial affairs run by a foreign bank, its economy controlled by external boardrooms, Nato dictating defence policy and the EU in charge of much else. That really does begin to look like colonial status.

Of course we do need a liberation struggle - it's just that Scottish nationalism is not it. It is economic emancipation we are after.

As those old banners remind us the trade union and labour movement will be the best hope for building the better society. That is where advance for working people has always sprung from and always will.

No-one spoke of this socialism in our time with more conviction than Tony Benn. In his foreword to John Foster and Charles Woolfson's masterly volume on the UCS work-in he reflected on "the shipyard workers on the Clyde who lit a lamp of hope during their campaign for jobs and in doing so, opened up a real prospect for socialist transformation that one day will be realised."

Though he has left us, let this vision of hope live on.

 

Richard Leonard is GMB Scotland regional organiser and political officer

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You can read five articles for free every month,
but please consider supporting us by becoming a subscriber.
More from this author
Britain / 7 May 2014
7 May 2014
City believe technicality will prevent Uefa sanction Manchester City's refusal to accept sanctions for breaching Uefa's financial fair play (FFP) rules may be because the club believe they only failed on a technicality, financial analyst Ed Thompson believes.
Britain / 7 May 2014
7 May 2014
Shopworkers come out firmly against the government’s NHS privatisation agenda, declaring that the country only has a year to save it
Britain / 27 April 2014
27 April 2014
Racist changes to articles on Wikipedia glorying in killing or enslaving black people are linked to a government IP address, adding to scandal of a Wikipedia page on the Hillsborough disaster being amended to include the words “blame Liverpool fans”
Similar stories
A bus under construction at the Alexander Dennis bus manufacturers in Falkirk
Voices of Scotland / 17 June 2025
17 June 2025

As bus builder Alexander Dennis threatens Falkirk closure and Grangemouth faces ruthless shutdown by tax exile Jim Ratcliffe, RICHARD LEONARD MSP warns that global corporations must be resisted by a bold industrial strategy based on public ownership

MIXED HISTORY: The Kelvingrove Art Gallery has significant connections to profits made from the transatlantic slave trade and colonialism
Features / 29 April 2025
29 April 2025

That Scotland was an active participant and beneficiary of colonialism and slavery is not a question of blame games and guilt peddling, but a crucial fact assessing the class nature of the questions of devolution and independence, writes VINCE MILLS

SHINING EXAMPLE: John Foster
Book Review / 15 January 2025
15 January 2025
Emphasising his continuous engagement in labour movement struggles, ALISTAIR FINDLAY salutes John Foster’s contribution as activist, strategist, intellectual and defender of the Morning Star
Features / 14 November 2024
14 November 2024
ELAINE MCFARLAND and JIM WHISTON introduce a collection of essays published in honour of Professor John Foster