Skip to main content
Work with the NEU
The James Toney of Prizefighter was a far cry from the genius I remember
The over-the-hill boxer who appeared in the popular tournament this week was a shadow of the legend I saw train in the 1990s, says John Wight

No disrespect to Prizefighter, but the sight of an out-of-shape James “Lights Out” Toney sharing the ring with a line-up of journeymen in the heavyweight version of the tournament at London’s York Hall was a sad reminder that time waits for no athlete — even a legitmate ring legend such as Toney.

When it comes to the fighter who stood out as the most skilled, outrageous, and memorable character I ever saw train at Freddie Roach’s Wildcard Boxing Gym in LA back in the early noughties there’s no contest.

Toney wasn’t so much a fighter as a force of nature. Whenever he arrived at the gym with his entourage of true believers the atmosphere underwent an instant and palpable change.

The 95th Anniversary Appeal
Support the Morning Star
You have reached the free limit.
Subscribe to continue reading.
Similar stories
Katie Taylor (left) and Flora Pili (right) face off as boxing promoter Eddie Hearn looks on during a press conference at The Helix at Mahony Hall, Dublin, September 1, 2026
Women's Boxing / 2 September 2026
2 September 2026
Gareth “Gumpy” Walker
Men’s boxing / 7 August 2026
7 August 2026

JOHN WIGHT meets the former British champion whose greatest battles have been fought outside of the ring

Katie Taylor poses for photos inside Croke Park, Dublin after a press conference. The 39-year-old will face Flora Pili at Croke Park in Dublin on September 5 for the vacant WBC super lightweight title in the final fight of her decorated career, June 5, 2026
Women’s Boxing / 28 July 2026
28 July 2026

More than 80,000 tickets sold within minutes as Irish icon prepares for farewell fight

robinson and turpin
Men's boxing / 10 July 2026
10 July 2026

JOHN WIGHT pays tribute to the day in history when Randolph Turpin dealt the world of boxing an almighty blow